Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Nailed My Signature Thanksgiving Cocktail With These Bar Supplies
35
items Every November I'd try to recreate those fancy fall cocktails from Instagram and end up with a sticky counter and a drink that tasted like candle wax. If you're the one who hosts Thanksgiving and wants a drink station that actually impresses without ...
Sections
7
Pumpkin Spice Rimming Sugars and Salts
Fall Cocktail Syrups That Don't Taste Artificial
Bourbon and Whiskey Worth Mixing Into Fall Drinks
Cocktail Glasses That Make the Rimming Sugar Pop
Garnishes and Finishing Touches for Fall Drinks
Bar Tools for Rimming Glasses Like a Pro
Pumpkin Spice Rimming Sugars and Salts
I used to just dip glasses in plain sugar like some kind of amateur. The moment I switched to actual flavored rimming sugar, people started asking me for the recipe instead of reaching for the wine.
Grab this one first. I rimmed a bourbon apple cider with it last year and my mother-in-law literally wrote down the brand name on a napkin. Perfect for anyone hosting their first real Thanksgiving dinner.
Dell Cove Spices & More
Use this if you want a coarser grain that actually sticks to the glass and doesn't dissolve in two minutes. Tried three other brands before this one. The cinnamon comes through without tasting fake.
Rokz 1 lb. Mojito Cocktail Rimming Sugar
Keep this in your bar cart for quick rimming jobs. It's pre-mixed so you literally just dip and go. Saved me fifteen minutes of fumbling around when guests showed up early last year.
Twang-A-Rita Cocktail Rimming Salt Blend, Lime Variety
Pair this with dark rum drinks. The smokiness plays so well with fall flavors that my brother, who only drinks beer, asked for a second cocktail. Stock up because the jar goes faster than you'd think.
Pumpkin Spice Cocktail Recipe
Toss this in your cart if you're making batched cocktails for a crowd. It's forgiving with proportions and won't overpower lighter drinks like a prosecco spritz. Great for the friend who hates strong flavors.
The Spice Lab Pumpkin Spice Sugar Cocktail Rimmers
Fall Cocktail Syrups That Don't Taste Artificial
Half the pumpkin spice syrups out there taste like you melted a Yankee Candle into bourbon. Finding ones that actually taste like real spices took me three Thanksgivings of trial and error.
Swap this for whatever syrup you've been using from the coffee aisle. It dissolves clean in cold drinks, which most syrups won't do. I mix it into espresso martinis and nobody believes it's homemade-level easy.
Torani Pumpkin Pie Syrup
Use this one when you're making drinks for people who actually know cocktails. It's less sweet and more spice-forward. Brought it to friendsgiving and the guy who's a sommelier gave me a nod of approval.
Monin 750 mL Premium Pumpkin Spice Flavoring Syrup
Try this if you're watching sugar but still want a real cocktail, not sad sparkling water. I mixed it with vodka and oat milk over ice and it tasted like a dessert without the guilt spiral afterward.
Jordan's Skinny Mixes, Pumpkin Spice Syrup, 25.4 Fl Oz
Snag this for thicker, latte-style cocktails. It's not technically a bar syrup but shake it hard with bourbon and cream and you get this velvety texture that a thin syrup can't pull off.
Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte Syrup Sauce, 1.86 L Bottle
Keep this as your backup bottle. The flavor leans more nutmeg and clove than straight cinnamon, which works beautifully in warm toddies. For anyone who drinks their cocktails hot, this one's your pick.
DaVinci Gourmet Sugar-Free Pumpkin Pie Syrup
Bourbon and Whiskey Worth Mixing Into Fall Drinks
I wasted money on expensive sipping bourbon for mixed drinks before realizing you need something bold enough to stand up to pumpkin spice, not something delicate that disappears.
Grab this as your workhorse Thanksgiving bourbon. Vanilla and caramel notes already lean fall, so you're not fighting the spirit to make it taste seasonal. Runs about $25 and punches way above that.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Use this in an old fashioned with pumpkin spice syrup. The high rye content gives it a spicy kick that matches cinnamon perfectly. My go-to since 2021 and I've never once been disappointed.
Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey, 750 mL, 45% ABV
Try this if your cocktails keep tasting watered down. The higher proof means the bourbon flavor actually survives ice, mixers, and rimming sugar. Built for drinks, not just sipping neat.
Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon Review
Pair this with apple cider and a cinnamon stick. The wheated mash bill makes it softer and rounder, so it won't overpower lighter fall ingredients. Perfect for guests who say they don't like whiskey.
Maker's Mark
Snag this for batch cocktails when you're serving twelve people and can't justify $30 a bottle times four. Honest, solid bourbon that disappears into a good recipe. Nobody will know or care.
Official Home of Atlassian Williams F1 Team
Cocktail Glasses That Make the Rimming Sugar Pop
Serving a fancy drink in a regular tumbler is like putting a steak on a paper plate. The right glass makes that sugar rim look intentional instead of sloppy.
Ditch your old martini glasses for these. The wide rim gives you maximum sugar surface area and they don't tip over every time someone bumps the table. Bought mine two years ago, haven't broken one yet.
Libbey Capone Coupe Cocktail Glasses
Use these for stirred bourbon drinks. The cut crystal catches light and makes even a simple cocktail look like it costs $18 at a restaurant. Heavy enough that they feel expensive in your hand.
Godinger 25722 Dublin Crystal Whiskey Glass 11oz, Set of 4
Try these if you have kids running around during Thanksgiving. No stems means fewer shattered glasses. The flared rim holds sugar perfectly and they're dishwasher safe, which is all I care about on cleanup day.
JoyJolt Afina Stemless Martini Glasses Set of 4
Swap these in for highball drinks with ginger beer or cider. The textured glass hides fingerprints, which matters when twenty people are grabbing drinks. They look vintage without the thrift store gamble.
Bormioli Rocco Romantic Water Glass, 11.5 oz., Set of 6
Keep a set of these for guests who want wine but you want them to try your cocktail. Pour a spritz in here and suddenly it's a wine-shaped cocktail experience. Sneaky but effective.
Luminarc 21 oz. Cachet Clear Stemless Wine 4 PC
Garnishes and Finishing Touches for Fall Drinks
The garnish is what makes people pull out their phone to take a photo before drinking. Learned this the hard way when I served perfect cocktails that looked completely boring.
Toss one in every glass. It's the easiest garnish that looks like you tried hard. Float it next to an orange peel and suddenly your bourbon cider looks like it belongs on a food blog. Costs almost nothing.
Is McCormick Cinnamon Cassia or Ceylon?
Drop one of these in a clear cocktail and watch everyone ask what it is. The licorice scent hits before the first sip, which layers the whole drinking experience. For the host who wants that extra dramatic moment.
Badia Star Anise, .5 oz Bottle
Grab a small jar and grate fresh over cream cocktails right before serving. The difference between pre-ground and freshly grated is wild. Did this at last year's dinner and my sister texted me the next day asking how.
Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg, 2.3 oz, (Pack of 6)
Skewer three on a cocktail pick and lay across the rim. The deep red against pumpkin spice sugar looks incredible. Way cheaper than buying fancy cocktail garnishes and people actually eat them after.
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Dried Sweetened
Pair two dashes with any bourbon pumpkin drink. It rounds out the sweetness so your cocktail doesn't taste like dessert in a glass. If you only buy one bar ingredient this year, this is the one. Lasts forever.
Aromatic Bitters
Bar Tools for Rimming Glasses Like a Pro
First Thanksgiving I hosted, I tried to rim glasses by just pressing them into a pile of sugar on a plate. Half the sugar fell off, the other half was uneven. These tools fixed that embarrassment.
Use this instead of a flat plate. You put lime juice in one tier and sugar in the next, spin the glass, done. Perfectly even rim every single time. Took me from messy to clean in one purchase.
Salt Rimmer Sets for Home Bars
Shake your fall cocktails hard with ice to get them frothy. This one doesn't leak, which sounds basic but my last three shakers all dripped everywhere. The built-in strainer saves washing another tool.
OXO Steel Cocktail Shaker with Strainer
Try this for stirred drinks instead of shaken. The long handle reaches the bottom of any pitcher, and the twisted shaft lets you stir smoothly without splashing. Perfect if you batch cocktails in a big jar.
Hiware 2-Pack 12 Inches Stainless Steel Mixing Spoons
Snag this for fresh lemon and orange juice in your fall drinks. Bottled juice tastes flat in cocktails, and this gets every last drop without seeds. My hands used to cramp squeezing citrus by hand. Problem solved.
Zulay Kitchen Large Manual Citrus Juicer Press
Keep this around for drinks with muddled spices or fruit. Nobody wants chunks of cinnamon bark floating in their glass. Fits snugly over any mixing glass and catches everything. Cleanup takes ten seconds.
Norpro Stainless Steel Strainer - Pack of 6
Batch Cocktail Mixers for When You Don't Want to Play Bartender All Night
Hosting means you're already cooking, cleaning, and managing family drama. Standing behind a makeshift bar mixing individual drinks for three hours is not how I want to spend my Thanksgiving.
Toss a sachet into a pot of cider with bourbon and let it simmer. Walk away. Come back to a house that smells incredible and a drink that's already done. Hosting hack I wish someone told me five years ago.
Williams Sonoma Mulling Spices
Pour this into a pitcher with tequila and a splash of pumpkin spice syrup for a fall margarita that serves eight. Sounds weird, tastes unreal. My cousin who hates pumpkin spice had three glasses.
Tres Agaves Organic Non-Alcoholic Lime Margarita Mix
Pair this with bourbon and a squeeze of lemon for a fall mule. The ginger has actual bite, not that flat soda taste from cheaper brands. Set bottles out with instructions and let people make their own.
Fever Tree Premium Ginger Beer
Use this as a cocktail base or a standalone for non-drinkers so nobody feels left out. Add a splash of vanilla vodka and rimming sugar and it becomes a legit cocktail in thirty seconds flat.
Martinelli's Apple Juice
Switch to this from store brand tonic and taste the difference immediately. Less sweet, more botanical, pairs with gin and autumn spices without clashing. For anyone who's been blaming the gin when it was really the tonic all along.
Customer reviews for Q MIXERS TONIC WATER with LIME