Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Holy Grail Self-Tanning Guide

Purple Star emoji 16 items
You want to try self-tanning, but you don't want to look orange…I've got you! As a redhead, orange is not my color. I've tested several self-tanning lines and these are my absolute favorite finds that I use over and over again.
Sections
4
 
 
 
 

Pre-Tanning Routine

Step 1: SHAVE. EVERYTHING.
Step 2: Use an exfoliating mitt & sugar scrub to get rid of dry patches and dead skin flakes. This creates a flawlessly smooth surface for the self-tanner to apply to!

 
Exfoliating Mitt for Self-Tan Prep | Peta Jane Beauty
 
Black & Terracotta Exfoliating Glove 2pc Set - Kitsch | Ulta Beauty
 
Lychee Kiss Shea Sugar Scrub - Tree Hut | Ulta Beauty
 
Venus Sensitive 3-Blade Women's Disposable Razors - 3ct
 
Skintimate Signature Scents Raspberry Rain Women's Shave Gel Twin Pack - 14oz

Self-Tanning Products

As a natural redhead, I can't risk a self-tanner pulling orange on my skin. Yikes! These two self-tanning mousses have been my ride or die faves for a natural-looking olive brown tan. *chefs kiss*

 
6.7 oz 2 HR Express Platinum Self-Tanning Mousse - Loving Tan | Ulta Beauty
 
Peta Jane Beauty Self-Tanning Mousse - Streak-Free Natural Color, Sunless Tanner, Quick Drying, Vegan - Ultra Dark - 7 fl oz - Beauty Studio
 
Peta Jane Beauty Self-Tanning Face and Body Mist - 7 fl oz - Beauty Studio
 
Dark 2 HR Express Face Tanning Serum - Loving Tan | Ulta Beauty
 
Peta Jane Beauty Gradual Self Tanning Face Lotion, Non-Comedogenic Buildable Face Tanner, Vegan - 1.7 fl oz - Beauty Studio

Self-Tanning Tools

Using a quality self-tanning mitt can make all the difference. You don't want streaks and you also don't want the mitt to absorb tons of product. I've used both of these mitts along with the body & face perfecting brushes to make sure I get an even application with as little effort as possible.

 
Self-Tanning Applicator Mitt - Loving Tan | Ulta Beauty
 
Peta Jane Beauty Self-Tanning Applicator Mitt - Reusable Streak-Free Tanning Mitt, Waterproof Lining - Beauty Studio
 
Peta Jane Beauty Self-Tan Body Blending Brush - Beauty Studio
 
Peta Jane Beauty Self Tan Face Blending Brush - Beauty Studio

To Remove Old Self-Tan

When your tan begins to fade and you're ready to refresh, don't just apply another layer of self-tanner. Trust me…it won't adhere to your skin properly and you'll look SO patchy. Instead, use this remover and an exfoliating mitt to get rid of the old...

 
3.3 oz Deluxe Tan Remover - Loving Tan | Ulta Beauty
 
Tan Removing & Skin Polishing Glove