Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
ONE-derful Gifts That Outgrow the Bow 💝
32
items Cass is turning 1 the week of Halloween.
And here are the “family items + birthday gifts + toddler necessities” we’ve either already purchased for her, or are adding to her birthday list.
Sections
10
Halloween Birthday
Books
Toys
Bedding
Gear
Diapers & Training Pants
Halloween Birthday
A festive keepsake Cass can use year after year. This custom bag is double-lined for quality, soft enough to fold and store away, and sturdy enough to hold all the Halloween treats. With her name on it, it makes trick-or-treating feel extra special w...
Kids Personalized Halloween Basket, Custom Name Tote
For Cass’s birthday, we’re becoming her official ‘monster managers’ — just like Mike Wazowski was to Sully in the first movie. These hats make it fun and easy to join in on the theme without a full costume. Bonus: they double as the perfect family Ha...
Monsters Inc. Hats
Cass fell in love with this the moment we unboxed it — the soft fur texture and bright color had her hooked. When we tried it on, she didn’t want to take it off! It’s cozy, adorable, and such an easy Halloween idea for both boys and girls.
SULLY Blue Monster Jumpsuit Costume Kids
Books
Every child needs a Dr. Seuss collection!
I had one growing up and I loved every single book dearly. Now I want Cass to experience the same joy of imagination.
Dr Seuss A Classic Case 20 Book Set Box Collection Pack
A special gift for your little one’s library — a beautifully illustrated book of myths to honor your family’s roots.
Cass’ dad is of Scottish descent, and this is a way we can spark imagination while connecting her to heritage and storytelling tradi...
Celtic Myths & Legends
Another keepsake worthy addition to your little one’s library.
Scottish Folk & Fairy Tales
You can honor every side of your children’s family origin.
For example: Cass’ paternal grandmother is partially Chinese.
Chinese Myths & Legends
This board book set introduces your little one to great scientists in a fun, colorful, and baby-friendly way.
Little Scientist Board Book Set
Toys
This dry erase easel is perfect for doodles, practicing letters, or just letting their imagination run wild. Easy to wipe clean and reuse, it’s a keepsake piece they’ll enjoy for years.
And if they grow out of it, keep it to display memories.
Melissa & Doug Deluxe Standing Art Easel - Dry-Erase Board, Chalkboard, Paper Roller - FSC Certified
Around age one, babies are pulling up, cruising, and eager to explore — the Pikler Triangle gives them a safe space to practice those skills. As they grow, it transforms into endless climbing, sliding, and imaginative play.
COSYLAND Pikler Triangle 8-in-1 Montessori
Bedding
A practical but thoughtful gift for transitioning from crib to big kid bed. This soft bed rail bumper keeps your little one safe from rolling out while still feeling cozy and independent. Easy to install & travel-friendly.
Extra Long Foam Bedrail Bumper
The Dream Easy Pillow gives your little one gentle support and comfort as they transition from crib sleeping. Soft, breathable, and perfectly sized for small heads, it makes bedtime feel safer, cozier, and a little more grown-up.
Dream Easy™ Kids Pillow
A nightlight provides comfort, security, and a soothing glow that helps them fall back asleep on their own. Practical for parents, magical for toddlers — a gift that makes bedtime easier for everyone.
Kids Night Lights & Baby Night Lights
A beautiful keepsake gift that’s perfect for a 1st birthday. We chose this quilt for Cass because it reflects her happy and vibrant personality — and that’s exactly why it makes such a meaningful gift for any little one.
Heritage Sunshine Rainbows Quilt & Shams
Gear
We upgraded Cass out of her infant seat into this, and it’s honestly the best $200 we’ve ever spent. It fits perfectly in our sedan (no bulky struggle), feels super cushioned for long rides, and is way more affordable than most ‘luxury’ brands. Safe,...
Saffron SI 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat - Thunder - REBEL
One of the best 1st birthday gifts because it grows with your little one and brings them right into the heart of family life. A kitchen tower lets toddlers safely stand at counter height so they can explore, play, and eventually help with cooking. Pe...
Ergobaby Evolve KITCHEN TOWER - Natural Wood | Babylist Shop
Diapers & Training Pants
It may not be the most glamorous 1st birthday gift, but it’s one every parent will truly appreciate. By this age, most babies are sizing up, and having a stash of Size 5 diapers is always a lifesaver.
Size 5 Soft and Absorbent Diapers
Around this stage, many toddlers start transitioning toward potty training, and training pants make the process so much easier. They pull on like underwear, protect against accidents, and help little ones feel more independent.
Clear+Dry® Natural Disposable Diaper Pants
Bath Care
A smart and practical 1st birthday gift since this is the stage when brushing becomes part of the daily routine.
It’s also inexpensive and small enough to bundle with other essentials, like toddler toothbrushes, for a thoughtful and useful gift set.
Kid's Crest Cavity Protection Sparkle Fun Toothpaste
A practical add-on gift that saves parents money and makes life easier. Instead of buying a brand-new toothbrush each time, replacement heads keep things hygienic and cost-effective. Pair these with a kids’ toothbrush and cavity toothpaste, and you’v...
Papablic Replacement Toothbrush Heads 4ct
This is the toothbrush we’re choosing for Cass.
The Papablic BabyHandy makes brushing easier with its gentle sonic vibrations and tiny brush heads sized perfectly for little mouths. Designed for ages 0–3, it helps establish healthy habits early — an...
Papablic BabyHandy 2-Stage Sonic Toothbrush 0-3Y
Education
A fun and educational fraction game that makes a great gift for families with multiple kids. While it’s a little advanced for a 1-year-old, it’s something older siblings can enjoy right away.
MathMaster
A colorful, hands-on toy that doubles as a learning tool. These snap together easily, making them perfect for little hands to build towers and patterns now — and later, they’ll be great for counting, sorting, and early math skills. It’s never too ear...
Learning Resources MathLink Cubes 115 Pc Set
Furniture
The ULTIMATE big gift for a 1st birthday! A play kitchen sparks imagination, creativity, and hours of pretend play. At this age, little ones love to mimic mom and dad, and this all-in-one set lets them “cook” right alongside you. It’s sturdy, timeles...
Chelsea All-in-1 Toddler Play Kitchen (36")
A milestone 1st birthday gift we will personally buy Cass.
A floor bed gives them independence and freedom to explore safely, while still feeling cozy and secure. Choosing a queen size means room to grow — it works all the way through their tween yea...
Queen Floor Bed with Safety Guardrails, Rubber Wood Montessori, Convertible Door
Everyone needs a step stool.
A practical and thoughtful 1st birthday gift that grows with your toddler’s independence. A double step stool gives them a safe boost for reaching sinks, counters, and shelves as they learn to do more on their own.
Classic Double Step Stool
First-Aid
Because what kid doesn’t love candy? Lolleez are organic, throat-soothing lollipops made just for little ones. They taste like a treat but are also great for easing sore throats or teething discomfort.
Lolleez Organic Lollipops for Kids, 28 Ct
It may not be the most glamorous gift, but it’s one every parent will be thankful for. A stocked first aid kit is a practical 1st birthday present that ensures moms and dads have everything on hand for life’s little bumps and scrapes.
Protect Life Survival First Aid Kit - 100pcs
The deluxe version goes beyond the basics — with supplies to handle everything from toddler bumps and bruises to family emergencies. A perfect 1st birthday gift that parents may not think to buy themselves, but will always be grateful to have on hand...
Deluxe Family First Aid Kit | Red Cross Store
Just like the ColdCalm drops, but easier for on-the-go. These homeopathic pellets help relieve runny noses and congestion, and they’re gentle enough for little ones. A practical wellness gift parents can toss in the diaper bag for sniffle emergencies...
Boiron ColdCalm Kids Pellets, 2 Count
A homeopathic remedy that helps ease mild fevers, runny noses, and cold symptoms — and it actually works.
Boiron ColdCalm Kids Drops - 30 Count
Probiotics help balance digestion, ease constipation, and support immunity — all things toddlers need as they grow and explore new foods. Easy to bundle with first aid or wellness kits, it’s a small but mighty gift parents will truly appreciate.
Lovebug Toddler Probiotics Organic Fiber