Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Buy at Your Own Risk

Purple Star emoji 5 items
This is a curated list of products that I had high hopes for (they even have great ratings and reviews) but they did not personally work for me! They may work for you though, but I would proceed with caution. This is kind of backwards, maybe, but I b...
Sections
3
 
 
 

Make-Up

Makeup items that did not work well for me!

 
Amy Edelman profile picture
This ELF Cosmetics Halo Glow skin tint is rated a 4.4 on the website so it clearly is working for some. However, this skin tint was cakey on me, it creased on my skin and the color match was off. That's not my usual experience with elf.
5 Light Warm Halo Glow Skin Tint Mineral SPF 50 - e.l.f. Cosmetics
 
Amy Edelman profile picture
Sitting at a 4.3 rating on Ulta, but I did not like it. I saw this all over my tik tok thinking it would be great! I got shade light medium, it kind of caked onto my skin. I have way better options elsewhere. But it might work for you! Maybelline Fit...
20 Light Medium Fit Me Loose Finishing Powder - Maybelline
 
Amy Edelman profile picture
I got this in Pink Perfection. The color is gorgeous, I swatched it in the stores and loved it. However, when I used it on my eyes I did not like the creamy cold texture and the shimmer kind of smeared itsself away. I am willing to try another one, b...
Pink Perfection Jelly Much Gel Eyeshadow Stick

Skincare

Skincare that gave me issues but had great reviews!

 
Amy Edelman profile picture
Sitting at a 4.3 rating on Ulta's website, but this face wash actually cleansed my skin but caused peririal dermatitis around my nose/mouth. It clearly works for many, but I was the outcast here.
6.7 oz The Cult Classic Purifying Face Cleanser - TULA

Feminine Care

Female oriented items did not check the boxes

 
Amy Edelman profile picture
Ladies, save your money here. This Cosmopolitan Plus One Gem would not charge properly, it was kind of awkward to hold and it...just.wasn't.it. Find a better option, but maybe your experience will be different!
Cosmopolitan X plusOne Girls' Best Gem Vibrator - plusOne