Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Your Fall 2025 Reading List

Purple Star emoji 22 items
Cozy up with books that capture autumn's magic, from atmospheric classics and dark academia favorites to enchanting contemporary tales. These stories wrap you in the season's mood with their rich settings, mysterious undertones, and that perfect blen...
Sections
6
 
 
 
 
 
 

Gothic Classics + Dark Foundations

The original masters of atmospheric storytelling, these timeless tales established the blueprint for autumn reading.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A fall reading list cannot exist without this essential read.
The Legend of Sleepy Hollow and Other Stories
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Get in girls, we're going to read Mary Shelley and yap.
Frankenstein: The 1818 Text
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Fall = Brontë Sister Season
Jane Eyre
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
It's a Brontë Girl Autumn.
Wuthering Heights
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A seasonal classic that's irresistibly creepy.
We Have Always Lived in the Castle: (Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition)
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Scaring kids since junior high literature, still scaring me today.
The Haunting of Hill House
placeholder

Dark Academia + Scholarly Mysteries

Ivy-covered halls, secret societies, and intellectual intrigue that'll make you want to study by lamplight.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
It's kind of the perfect book for autumn.
Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators' Revolution
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
It's the definitive modern fall read.
The Secret History: A Novel
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
"'Heathers' gone to grad school." —Booklist
Bunny: A Novel
placeholder

Witchy Women + Magical Realism

Stories where magic runs through bloodlines and ordinary women discover extraordinary power.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
The perfect witchy fall romance!
Practical Magic: 25th Anniversary Edition
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A beautiful and haunting historical fiction that's perfect for fall.
Weyward: A Novel
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
An unexpectedly original take on Lady Macbeth that screams fall reading list.
Lady Macbeth: A Novel
placeholder

Enchanted + Otherworldly

Contemporary fantasies that transport you to places where wonder and melancholy intertwine.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Mesmerizing and the perfect fall escape.
The Night Circus: A Novel
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A haunting and beautiful love story that I couldn't put down.
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Surreal and seasonally perfect for a transportive fall.
Piranesi
placeholder

Cozy Gothic Romances

Love stories with shadows and secrets—perfect when you want your heart to race for multiple reasons.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
It's haunting and hilarious at the same time.
The Dead Romantics: A GMA Book Club Pick
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A YA read that's perfect for the season, and it's written by one of my favorite podcast hosts/guests!
Anatomy: A Love Story
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
The perfect creepy fall read, it's an absolute delight.
Mexican Gothic
placeholder

Nostalgic + Contemplative

Books that wrap you in the warmth of memory and the bittersweet beauty of growing up.

 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A cherished read that you should definitely add to your autumn girl TBR
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A cherished classic that feels like a cozy cup of tea on a sun porch in the fading afternoon light.
Anne of Green Gables
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
Do you love fall fiction? Do you love Japanese translated fiction? This one's for you!!
Before the Coffee Gets Cold
placeholder
 
Amy Matthews profile picture
A pandemic ghost story? It's so much more than that.
The Sentence: A Novel
placeholder