Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
The Gelato Edit: NYC's Best Scoops Worth the Walk
14
items Not all gelato is created equal. These are the spots I'd cross boroughs for — ultra-creamy, made-fresh-daily, and seriously Instagrammable. Consider this your cheat sheet to the best gelato in New York City.
The UWS neighborhood gem that regulars swear by. Small batch, intensely flavored, and rotated often — the pistachio alone is worth the trip uptown. This is what gelato tastes like when someone actually cares.
Noi Due Gelato
A distinctly global flavor menu — think tahini, halva, and rose alongside the classics. The portions are generous and the texture is impossibly silky. A total crowd-pleaser with something for everyone.
Anita Gelato
The Italian luxury chocolate house that also happens to make exceptional gelato. Yes, it's a chain — but when the quality is this good, we don't gatekeep. The chocolate hazelnut is non-negotiable.
Venchi NYC Union Square Store, Broadway
A true artisan operation with an ever-changing seasonal menu that keeps you coming back. The flavors feel deeply Italian without being predictable. If they have the ricotta fig, get it. No questions.
Figo – Il Gelato Italiano
The OG of NYC artisan gelato — started on the Lower East Side and still setting the standard. Over 200 rotating flavors made in-house with zero shortcuts. This is the one food people fly to NYC and specifically seek out.
il laboratorio del gelato
Straight from Bologna with a cult following for good reason. Every flavor is made with single-origin ingredients and you can absolutely taste the difference. The stracciatella here is a masterclass in simplicity done right.
Rivareno Gelato
The rose petal-shaped scoops are iconic for a reason, and the flavor quality actually holds up. Perfect for visitors and a surprisingly solid pick for locals too.
Amorino Gelato - New York Times Square
A quiet favorite tucked away from the tourist trail. The vibe is relaxed, the flavors are classic and well-executed, and the staff clearly love what they're making. Come for the coffee gelato, stay for everything else.
The Gelateria
Handmade daily with a rotating menu that leans into Italian tradition — no artificial anything. The kind of spot that makes you realize how much filler you've been tolerating at other places. A must for the gelato purists.
L'Artigiano Gelato
Made by a gelato champion (literally — Patrizia has the accolades to prove it) inside Eataly's Flatiron location. The production is visible, the flavors are impeccable, and it pairs perfectly with a Eataly haul. Elevated and worth every penny.
La Gelateria di Eataly by Patrizia Pasqualetti
A beloved Park Slope institution with an almost cult-like local following. Organic ingredients, dairy-free options that actually taste good, and a rotating seasonal menu that keeps things exciting. Brooklyn's best-kept gelato secret.
L'Albero Dei Gelati
A perfect pit stop mid-SoHo shopping session. The espresso is as good as the gelato, the aesthetic is effortlessly chic, and it never feels overcrowded. Ideal for a mid-afternoon reset.
Italian Gelateria & Coffee Bar in SoHo
A Chelsea Market staple that's earned its iconic status. Open late, wildly flavorful, and perfect for when you need a scoop after a High Line walk. The nutella swirl is dangerously good.
L'Arte Del Gelato
Repping the borough with handcrafted small-batch gelato and serious local pride. The flavors rotate with the seasons and always feel intentional. This is the one to shout out when someone asks what Brooklyn does best.
Dolce Brooklyn