Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 20 Mascaras Under $15 So You Don't Have To
36
items Spending $30 on mascara that flakes by noon is a special kind of frustrating. If you've cycled through luxury tubes that smudge, clump, or disappear by happy hour, this is the lineup that actually held up. Took me two years and way too many raccoon-e...
Sections
9
Lengthening Mascaras That Actually Show Up
Volumizing Formulas for Thin, Sad Lashes
Waterproof Options That Survive Everything
Tubing Mascaras for Clean Removal
Brown Mascaras for a Softer Look
Curling Mascaras for Straight, Stubborn Lashes
Lengthening Mascaras That Actually Show Up
Short, straight lashes run in my family. I spent years thinking length was something only falsies could fix until I stopped buying based on packaging and started paying attention to brush shape.
Grab this if your lashes are basically invisible without three coats of something expensive. One swipe and my coworker asked if I got extensions. Under $12 and it outperformed every prestige tube in my drawer.
Maybelline eye Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara 705-Brownish Black shade Fanning Reservoir brush Sealed in package InonasCosmetics
Use this on mornings when you have exactly 45 seconds for eye makeup. The comb brush separates every single lash without clumping. My sister stole mine and I had to reorder within a week.
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift Washable Mascara
For anyone who looked at a $5 price tag and thought ‘no way this works.’ It does. I wore it to a wedding in 90-degree heat and not a single flake. Stock up because it sells out constantly.
essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Try this if your lashes snap off every time you curl them. The biotin formula actually made mine feel thicker after a month. Paid $9 and felt like I got away with something.
CoverGirl Exhibitionist Stretch & Strengthen Mascara
Volumizing Formulas for Thin, Sad Lashes
My lashes are blonde and fine, so bare-faced I look like I have none at all. These are the tubes that finally gave me that full, thick look without piling on six layers.
Toss your $28 mascara and try this instead. Two coats gave me more volume than the high-end one I'd been repurchasing for years. Perfect for anyone tired of paying luxury prices for mediocre results.
NYX Professional Makeup Worth The Hype Mascara Black
Keep this in your rotation if you want volume without that crunchy, spider-leg situation. The formula stays soft all day. Wore it on a 14-hour travel day and it looked the same at landing.
Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara
Snag this if you have sensitive eyes that water at literally everything. Clean formula, zero irritation, and it still builds volume like nobody's business. Wish I'd found it before wasting money on three others.
Tower 28 MakeWaves Lengthening + Volumizing Mascara
Switch to this when your current mascara leaves you looking like you tried too hard. It gives a ‘naturally full lashes’ effect that people can't quite figure out. Subtle but noticeable, which is my favorite kind.
Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara
Waterproof Options That Survive Everything
Cried at my best friend's wedding, jumped in a pool at a Fourth of July party, got caught in a downpour walking to work. These stayed put through all of it.
Bring this to any event where tears are likely. Sobbed through two speeches at a rehearsal dinner and checked the mirror after expecting carnage. Nothing moved. Not a smudge.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara
For the person who sweats through every workout but still wants to look put together at the gym. This held up through a hot yoga class that had no business being that humid.
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Waterproof
Get this if you live somewhere it rains nine months of the year. Splurge-worthy but often on sale. My lashes looked curled and lifted even after walking 20 minutes in a Seattle drizzle.
Lancôme Idôle Lash Lifting Volumizing Mascara, Black
Try this on beach vacation days when you want to look cute in photos without worrying about humidity. Survived snorkeling in Mexico, which is a sentence I never thought I'd say about mascara.
Milk Makeup RISE Waterproof Mascara
Tubing Mascaras for Clean Removal
Waking up with black smudges under my eyes because I was too tired to wash my face properly was a nightly occurrence. Tubing formulas changed everything. They slide off with warm water, no scrubbing required.
Use this if you're the person who rubs their eyes constantly and then looks like a raccoon by 2 PM. It literally cannot smudge. Slides off in little tubes when you wash your face. Witchcraft.
Blinc Cosmetics Original Tubing Mascara - Black - 0.3 fl oz
Keep this at your desk for midday touch-ups that take ten seconds. It never clumps, never transfers to your lids, and removal is just warm water and gentle pressure. Perfect for contact lens wearers.
Clinique Lash Power Flutter-to-Full Mascara (Women)
Pair this with a no-makeup makeup look when you want people to think you just naturally have great lashes. It's so natural-looking my boyfriend didn't believe I was wearing any. Comes off like a dream.
Glossier Lash Slick Lift and Lengthen Tubing Mascara
Swap to this if you've been scrubbing your eyes raw with makeup remover every night. The tubing formula means removal is gentle and fast. Your under-eye area will thank you within a week.
The Volume Mascara - Kevyn Aucoin
Brown Mascaras for a Softer Look
Black mascara sometimes felt like too much on my fair skin, especially during the day. Switching to brown was one of those tiny changes that made my whole face look more natural and awake.
Wait, wrong product. Just kidding. But seriously, brown mascara deserves more credit than it gets for making your entire face look cohesive and soft without trying.
Major Headlines Double-Take Crème & Powder Blush Duo
Grab the brown shade if you're fair-skinned and black mascara makes you look startled. This gives definition without that harsh contrast. Wore it to brunch and got three compliments before the mimosas arrived.
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara
Try the brown version if you want something that looks polished for daytime meetings but not overdone. It's the ‘I woke up like this’ of mascaras. Also tubing, so zero smudging.
Brown Travel-Size Tartelette Tubing Mascara - Tarte
Use this for days when you want your eyes to look defined but soft. The brown shade is warm without being orangey. My mom borrowed it once and now she orders her own. That's the highest endorsement I know.
Définicils High Definition Lengthening Mascara
Curling Mascaras for Straight, Stubborn Lashes
No matter how long I held my lash curler, my lashes dropped flat within an hour. These formulas actually hold a curl without needing to clamp anything near my eyeball.
Snag this if your lashes point straight down like they're giving up on life. This Japanese formula held a curl for 16 hours on lashes that normally surrender in 20 minutes. I gasped the first time.
Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film
Get this for those mornings when you curled your lashes perfectly and they dropped flat by the time you got to your car. The formula sets the curl in place without feeling stiff or crunchy.
ControlledChaos MascaraInk | Volume Mascara
Try this if you've given up on curling mascaras because none of them actually curl. The tapered brush reaches every tiny lash and the hold lasts through a full workday. Found it by accident and never looked back.
Black Sparkle Volumising / Vegan Curling Mascara
Pair this with a good lash curler and your lashes will look like they're defying gravity all day. It's dramatic, sure, but sometimes you want that. Perfect for nights out when you want your eyes to do the talking.
Too Faced Naturally Better Than Sex Mascara
Mascaras That Won't Irritate Sensitive Eyes
Contact lenses plus sensitive eyes meant half the mascaras I tried left me red, itchy, and miserable by lunchtime. Finding formulas that don't burn took embarrassingly long.
Use this if every mascara you've tried makes your eyes water like you're watching a sad movie. Clean ingredients, no fragrance, no burning. Wore contacts all day with zero irritation for the first time in years.
Saie Mascara 101 with Beeswax
Keep this around if you care about what's actually in your mascara. Castor oil and peptides in the formula, so it conditions while you wear it. My lashes felt softer after a month of daily use.
Kosas The Big Clean Longwear Volumizing Lash Care
Grab this for sensitive eyes that react to basically everything. Mineral-based, no parabens, and it still gives solid volume. My eye doctor actually recommended mineral formulas and this one delivers.
LASHTOPIA® Mega Volume Mineral-Based Mascara
Switch to this if synthetic formulas make your eyelids puffy by end of day. The peptide complex strengthens lashes over time. Noticed less fallout after about three weeks, which alone made it worth trying.
RMS Beauty Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara
Mini Mascaras Worth Buying Before Committing
Nothing worse than spending $14 on a full-size mascara you hate. Minis let you test drive without the guilt of tossing a barely-used tube into the trash two weeks later.
Try the mini first because the full-size brush is intense and not everyone loves it. This way you spend $14 testing instead of committing. Learned this lesson the expensive way with three other brands.
Benefit Cosmetics Mini They're Real! Lengthening Mascara
Toss this in your travel bag when you don't want to risk your full-size leaking all over your toiletry pouch. The mini performs identically and lasts about six weeks of daily use.
Lancôme Idôle Lash Lifting Volumizing Mascara, Black
Get the mini if you're curious but skeptical about the hype. You'll know within a week whether you love the dramatic look or it's too much for your style. Low-risk way to find out.
Mini Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara - Too Faced
Snag the mini because the full-size is pricey and the formula is polarizing. Some people love the chunkiness, others hate it. Spend less figuring out which camp you're in.
Mini Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara
Mascara Tools That Made a Bigger Difference Than Expected
Realized halfway through this whole experiment that application matters almost as much as the formula itself. A few cheap tools completely changed how my mascara looked and lasted.
Use this before any mascara and watch the difference. My old drugstore curler was pinching and crimping. This one creates a smooth curve that holds. Spent $23 and saved myself from buying ‘curling’ mascaras that don't work.
Pro Master Lash Curler
Grab this for separating clumpy lashes after application. Run it through while the mascara is still wet and suddenly you look like you paid for a professional job. Takes five seconds and fixes everything.
SEPHORA COLLECTION Lift Off Lash Comb
Keep this in your makeup bag for cleaning up fallout under your eyes. Way easier than using a cotton swab and accidentally smearing concealer everywhere. Tiny tool, massive difference in how polished you look.
Angled Eyeliner/Brow Brush - Bamboo
Switch to this if your current curler doesn't fit your eye shape. The curve on this one works for rounder eyes that other curlers miss. Took me four different curlers to find the right fit and this was it.
Shiseido - Eyelash Curler