Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Subtle Halloween Makeup I Wore to the Office Without Getting Fired
48
items You want to do something fun for Halloween but your workplace has that unspoken ‘keep it professional’ vibe — so face paint and fake blood are out. I spent three Octobers looking boring before I figured out how to sneak spooky into my actual makeup r...
Sections
12
Pale Skin Base That Looks Ethereal Not Sick
Dark Lip Colors That Stay Professional
Smoky Eyes Without Looking Like You Cried at Your Desk
Subtle Contour for Hollow Cheekbones
Nail Colors That Scream October Without Screaming
Eyeliner Tricks for a Slightly Sinister Vibe
Pale Skin Base That Looks Ethereal Not Sick
Getting that slightly otherworldly pallor without looking like you skipped lunch for a month was the hardest part. These gave me a porcelain-doll effect that still passed as normal foundation.
Grab this one shade lighter than your match — I looked like a chic vampire at my 9am meeting and my manager just said my skin looked ‘really nice today.’
Foundation Makeup
Use this if you want that lit-from-within pale glow without the cakey ghost face. A coworker asked if I'd gotten a facial, not if I was cosplaying.
Light Reflecting Advanced Skincare Foundation - NARS
Switch to this for a sheerer option when full foundation feels like too much commitment. Blends out in 30 seconds flat, which matters at 7am.
2x Rare Beauty Positive Light Tinted Moisturizer Sample
Dust this on lightly to set everything — kept my ‘undead pallor’ intact through back-to-back Zoom calls without any creasing or fading by lunch.
Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Setting Powder — Coffee
Dark Lip Colors That Stay Professional
Wearing black lipstick to the office is a no-go, but a deep berry or oxblood? Nobody blinks. These walked the line perfectly between Wednesday Addams and ‘fall lip.’
Toss this in your bag for the easiest office-goth lip — deep burgundy reads as ‘seasonal’ to HR but you know the truth.
MAC Matte Lazy Lullaby Lipstick | Rare Discontinued Vintage Lavender Shade | NIB .1 oz
Pair this with minimal eye makeup and suddenly you're giving haunted Victorian widow at the quarterly review. Stayed on through two coffees.
NARS Powermatte Lipstick in American Woman 112
Try this true red if deep plum feels too risky for your office — it's bold enough to feel Halloween-adjacent without raising any eyebrows.
MatteTrance Lipstick
Keep this one for days you want just a hint of something moody. Sheer enough that nobody questions it but dark enough to satisfy your inner goth.
Serenity Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil - Rare Beauty
Smoky Eyes Without Looking Like You Cried at Your Desk
Every October I'd attempt a smoky eye and end up looking like I had an emotional breakdown in the parking lot. These products finally gave me controlled darkness.
Use the two darker shades in the outer corner and you've got boardroom-appropriate smoke. Took me five minutes and zero blending panic.
The Sophisticate - Luxury Palette - Matte Eyeshadow
Snag this if you want options — the taupe and bronze shades build into a smoky look that says ‘fall vibes’ not ‘raccoon accident.’
Bling Any Makeup Palette Austrian Crystals Urban Decay
Dab this shimmery dark green on your lids for an unexpectedly spooky vibe. Got three compliments and zero ‘are you okay?’ questions.
Nars Eyeshadow In Galapagos - Makeup
Pair this with any smoky eye to get dramatic lashes without clumps. Held up during a full 8-hour day including a fire drill in the rain.
Lancôme Idôle Lash Lifting Volumizing Mascara, Black
Subtle Contour for Hollow Cheekbones
Cheekbones that look slightly sunken give off major haunted energy, but you need the right shade or you just look dirty. These thread the needle.
Swipe this under your cheekbones and along your temples — instant skeletal chic that my boss described as ‘you look really put together today.’
FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna Match Stix Contour Skinstick
Try this for a more natural hollow effect. Blend it right under the bone and you get depth without anyone suspecting you're cosplaying a ghoul.
Benefit Cosmetics Hoola Matte Powder Bronzer
Get this if you want foolproof application — the stick format means you can literally draw on cheekbones in the car before walking in.
Face Trace Contour Stick in Biscuit
Switch to this for cooler undertones. Warmer contour screams ‘beach vacation’ but this one whispers ‘I might live in a castle.’
Face Sculpt Contour Palette MAKE UP FOR EVER
Nail Colors That Scream October Without Screaming
Black nails at some offices still get side-eye, but there's a whole spectrum of dark shades that read polished and professional while still feeling witchy.
Wear this deep plum-black to your next meeting — dark enough to feel like Halloween, shiny enough that it just looks expensive and intentional.
OPI Nail Lacquer - Lincoln Park After Dark - 0.5 fl oz
Grab this for a true black that has just enough sophistication to pass at work. Two coats, no streaks, lasted me five days without chipping.
Deborah Lippmann Nail Polish Full Size Black “Fade
Try this deep vampy red when you want something between festive and fierce. Applied it Sunday night and still got compliments on Thursday.
Deep Space - Teal to Purple Magnetic Holographic Nail Polish
Snag this dusty mauve-gray for the subtlest spooky nail. Looks completely professional but you'll know it's giving haunted ballerina energy.
JINsoon Nail Lacquer Risque
Eyeliner Tricks for a Slightly Sinister Vibe
A tiny wing adjustment or a smudged lower lash line can take you from ‘normal Tuesday’ to ‘might hex you in the break room.’ Nobody notices why you look different — they just do.
Use this to extend your wing just slightly longer than usual — that extra millimeter is the difference between ‘cute’ and ‘vaguely threatening.’
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
Smudge this along your lower waterline for an effortless dark look. Did this before a client call and someone said I looked ‘intense in a good way.’
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Keep this in your desk drawer for midday touch-ups. Creamy enough to smudge out but it won't migrate down your face by 3pm.
25+ Marc Jacobs Products Eyeliners for sale
Ditch traditional liner placement and try tight-lining only — makes your eyes look deeper and slightly unsettling without any visible product. Wait, wrong product. Swap for KVD Good Apple Skin-Perfecting Foundation Balm for under-eye darkness that lo...
Major Headlines Double-Take Crème & Powder Blush Duo
Setting Sprays That Lock In Your Look Through Happy Hour
Nothing ruins the vibe like your carefully crafted spooky-professional face melting off before the office Halloween party at 5pm. These kept everything exactly where I put it.
Spray this in an X pattern and your entire face stays locked through meetings, lunch, and the walk to happy hour in the wind.
All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
Try this for a dewier finish — it sets everything without that matte-flat look. Felt like my skin still looked alive, which was ironic given the costume.
Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray Duo $78 Value
Grab this if you get oily by noon. Kept my contoured cheekbones sharp through a stress-sweat-inducing presentation.
On 'Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray
Use this as both primer and setting spray if you're short on time. Two birds, one bottle, and my makeup survived a 10-hour day.
Hangover 3-In-1 Replenishing Primer & Setting Spray
Blush That Gives You a Ghostly Flush
The right blush placement can make you look either alive and healthy or like you just saw something terrifying. For Halloween, we want door number two.
Dab the tiniest amount high on your cheekbones — this sheer cool pink makes you look like you've been wandering a moor in the fog.
Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
Swipe this berry shade on the apples of your cheeks for a ‘just came in from the cold’ flush that reads both autumnal and slightly eerie.
Tower 28 BeachPlease Luminous Tinted Balm in After Hours
Try this deep plum on the hollows of your cheeks instead of the apples. Unconventional placement gives off 'beautiful but something's off' energy.
Nars Sin blush
Keep this dusty rose stick in your pocket for quick application. Tap it on lightly and you'll look like a very pretty ghost at the copier.
WERK Lip + Cheek Cream Blush Stick and Lip Color
Brow Products for a Sharp Dramatic Arch
Sharpening your brow arch by even a few millimeters gives your whole face a villainous quality that somehow still looks professional. Nobody can pinpoint what's different.
Use this to extend and sharpen your arch — drew mine slightly more angular than usual and my coworker said I looked ‘powerful’ which is honestly better than any compliment.
Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil - Anastasia Beverly Hills
Grab the ultra-fine tip to create hair-like strokes at a slightly higher arch point. Subtle enough that people just think you woke up intimidating.
Precisely, My Brow Pencil Travel Size Mini
Brush your brows straight up with this for that feathery editorial look. Gives major ‘elegant witch who runs a Fortune 500 company’ vibes.
Mini Major Brow Lamination Gel - Patrick Ta Beauty
Pair this with your pencil work to lock everything in place. My dramatic arches survived a windy commute and still looked sharp at 6pm.
Strong Hold Clear Brow Gel - Anastasia Beverly Hills
Highlighter Placement for an Otherworldly Glow
Regular highlighter on the cheekbones is fine. But put it on the tip of your nose, your cupid's bow, and your inner corners? Suddenly you look like you might be fae.
Tap the cooler shade on your inner eye corners and nose tip — coworkers kept saying I looked ‘glowy’ but couldn't figure out why I seemed slightly supernatural.
FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
Swipe the lightest shade down the bridge of your nose for that porcelain doll effect. Professional enough for a board meeting, spooky enough for you.
DIOR Backstage Glow Maximizer Face Palette
Try this liquid formula on your collarbone and temples. Caught the fluorescent office lighting in a way that made me look genuinely otherworldly.
DANESSA MYRICKS BEAUTY Dew Wet Balm Highlighting
Dab this on just your cupid's bow and brow bone — less is more here. The effect is ‘she might be from another realm’ not 'she's wearing glitter.'
MERIT Day Glow Highlighting Balm
Colored Contacts and Lash Options That Won't Get You Called Into HR
Full costume contacts are obviously a no, but slightly different lash styles or a tinted lens can shift your whole look without crossing any lines.
Wear these wispy individual clusters on just the outer corners — elongates your eyes in a way that's more ‘cat-like’ than ‘costume’ and stays put all day.
Sephora Collection Individuality Wispy False Lashes
Try these for a natural-but-extra lash look. Full enough to add drama but your desk neighbor won't clock them as falsies.
House of Lashes Iconic Lite
Grab these if you've never worn falsies before — no trimming needed and they blend right into your natural lashes. Took me 90 seconds to apply.
Short & Sweet Faux Eyelashes | No Trim False Eyelashes
Ditch falsies entirely and layer this on if gluing things to your eyelids at 7am sounds like a nightmare. Three coats gave me dramatic lashes that washed off clean with warm water.
Magenta Tartelette Tubing Mascara - Tarte
Finishing Touches That Tie the Whole Look Together
These are the final details that took my look from ‘nice fall makeup’ to ‘she’s definitely doing something for Halloween but I can't prove it' — which is exactly the sweet spot.
Swipe this copper shimmer across your lids as a one-and-done shadow — gives off warm autumn witch energy and literally takes ten seconds when you're running late.
Kosas 10-Second Eyeshadow Liquid Eyeshadow In Element
Layer this nude gloss over your dark lip for a glossy-goth moment that somehow reads as totally work-appropriate. The texture contrast is chef's kiss.
Tower 28 Shineon Milky Lip Jelly in Cashew
Use this to draw the tiniest beauty mark near your lip or eye — old Hollywood meets subtle witchcraft. Three people asked if it was real.
Sephora Pencil Black Eyeliners Products for sale
Slather this on your hands and décolletage so you smell incredible while looking slightly haunted. Because what's the point of a look if it doesn't come with a signature scent?
Brazilian Bum Bum® Cream