Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
New Buffalo, MI cutest beach town MUSTS!
13
items The past three summers we have made our summer beach trip in this area because the weather is amazing! Perfect for the beach and pool but evenings you can wear a long sleeve or light sweatshirt and sit by a fire. We won’t have it any other way for a ...
Map
HOLY Beer! Fun atmosphere right in the heart of the town, easy access, great food, drinks, ice cream & merch! A must try when visiting!
Beer Church Brewing Co.
Every time we visit we book a date night here because the food is phenomenal & the atmosphere is on point! Italian cuisine & exquisite cocktails! Another must try!
Terrace Room
If you’re looking for a fun late night spot while visiting New Buffalo, MI- this was a hit open until 2 AM and the back patio is large & spacious with plenty of seating!
Casey's New Buffalo
NEW to the New Buffalo area! We had to try this out immediately when we got into town for lunch! The menu is unique. I will say it wasn’t a huge menu however everything we had was delicious! Must try when visiting!
PostBoy
The chicest coffee spot you must check out! Insanely unique and impressive coffees and lattes as well as amazing food options! Must try when visiting!
Issa Vibe Café
You must check out this hidden gem of a beach when traveling to New Buffalo! There’s a public beach of course but this is a smaller quiet public beach that has small amount of parking and I will say there is a long staircase but it’s worth it!
TOWNLINE ROAD BEACH - Updated July 2025 - 20 Photos - Town Line Ave, ...
Delicious beer and food! We enjoyed the patio and also the Amtrak (train that travels to Chicago) is right next to it so the kids loved watching that pass by!
Ghost Isle Brewery
We loved getting coffee, fresh pastry and flowers from this adorable shop! The vibe and atmosphere is so peaceful and inviting!
Farmette
Cutest little cocktail bar. Stays open late until 1 am with both indoor and outdoor service
Hummingbird Lounge
Local staple, if you visit during a popular time you will definitely have a wait just fyi! Also, can get some of their pizzas frozen and take back to your airbnb to heat and enjoy at home! Yummmm
Villa Nova Pizzeria New Buffalo
Delectable snacks, coffees and goodies in this adorable shop! It’s actually in Union Pier which is right next to new Buffalo and just a quick 5 minute drive down the road! Also they have by far the best pimento cheese dip we get every time!
Whistle Stop Grocery
The town grocery store :)
Barney's
(has a rooftop bar that is for adults only)
Cute tshirt shop connected!
-This is a popular spot for sure we went late one night for apps and had a child with us only but we never could get in for dinner time bc it was such a long wait so just heads...
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill