Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best Eyeliners + Mascara I’m Loving
24
items My favorite eyeliners for creating sharp wings, precise cat eyes, and smooth, richly pigmented lines. These picks are easy to control, long-wearing, and perfect for both everyday looks and full glam.
Map
Sections
3
Black eyeliners
COLORED LINERS
Mascaras Worth Trying
Black eyeliners
Note: These are my personal favorites, but results can vary depending on your eye shape, skin type, and sensitivity. Always check the ingredients and do a patch test first if your eyes are easily irritated.
I love this KIKO eyeliner for creating sharp wings and precise inner corners. The felt tip gives me good control, the black pigment shows up rich and even, and it glides on without needing too many passes. Once it sets, it stays clean and defined wit...
Micro Tip Eyeliner - KIKO
This liner gives such a rich, intense black finish and makes sharp wings feel effortless. The fine tip is easy to control for both thin lines and dramatic cat eyes, and the formula glides on smoothly without looking patchy. I also love how luxurious ...
GUCCI POWER LIQUID LINER ICONIC BLACK 010 0.5ml
This brow pencil makes filling in my brows feel sooo easy 😍 Love how soft and natural the finished look is, not too harsh or overly drawn on. Perfect for quick everyday brows. 🤎✨
Goof Proof Brow Pencil
COLORED LINERS
A curated edit of bold colored liners for sharp wings, creative cat eyes, and statement looks that pop on melanin-rich skin.
Fenty Beauty Trace’d Out Lip Liner — The MVP 💋
Trace'd Out Longwear Waterproof Pencil Lip Liner — The MVP
2
Obsessed with this liner 😍 Super sleek, creamy-looking, and perfect for getting that sharp little wing without the struggle. Definitely giving effortless glam. ✨🖤
BADgal Hypeliner | Longwear Gel Eyeliner
This blue is such a fun switch-up from basic black liner 💙✨ The shade looks bold without being too much, and I love how it instantly makes an eye look feel more playful. Perfect when you want a little pop of color.
MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil Waterproof Arctic Skies
That purple is sooo pretty 💜✨ Such a fun change from black or brown liner, and it adds just enough color without taking over the whole look. Perfect for making everyday makeup feel a little more playful.
REVLON ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner 214 Grape
This kajal is giving instant smoky-eye energy 🖤✨ I love how rich and dramatic the black looks, perfect for a soft smudge along the lash line or going full sultry glam. Such a makeup bag staple.
In Extreme Dimension 24-Hour Kajal Eye Liner
This orange liner is such a vibe 🧡✨ I love how bright and unexpected it is—it instantly makes a simple eye look feel fun and editorial without trying too hard. Perfect for when you want a little pop of color.
Chromagraphic Liner Pencil
This blue is sooo good 💙✨ It adds the perfect pop without feeling too wild, and I love how instantly it makes a simple eye look more fun. Such an easy way to switch up everyday makeup.
Epic Inky Stix Waterproof Cream Gel Eyeliner
Okay this rosy-brown shade is sooo pretty 🤎🌹 It feels softer than black but still gives the eyes that defined, pulled-together look. Such a cute everyday liner when you want something a little different but still wearable. ✨
Epic Inky Stix Waterproof Cream Gel Eyeliner
This liner is such a pretty little sparkle moment ✨🤍 I love how it adds that extra touch of glam without feeling too heavy. Perfect for inner corners, a fun wing, or layering over your usual liner when you want something a little more special.
Bridgerton Royal Epic Ink Glitz Liquid Liner | NYX Professional Makeup
Okayyy this pop of orange is SO cute 🧡✨ It makes a neutral eye look feel instantly more fun and editorial without doing too much. Such a good little makeup pick for summer nights, festivals, or anytime you want your eyes to be the moment.
NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick - Orange Zest
Obsessed with the **Stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner** for crisp wings, graphic liner + bold beauty looks ✨🤍 Super precise, long-wearing and perfect for creating sharp cat eyes or creative white eyeliner details. **Keywords:** Stila e...
Stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner – Smudge-Proof, Long-Lasting Eyeliner
A little pop of electric blue for when black liner feels way too predictable 💙✨ Perfect for adding a playful statement to any beauty look.
Barry M Hi Vis Bold Waterproof Eyeliner
Such a fun pop of pink for the eyes 💗 The color is bright, smooth, and perfect when you want your makeup to feel a little extra without doing too much.
NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick, Pink Spirit
Absolutely 💕 Here’s a cute, natural-sounding review you can paste: Obsessed with this shade! 💎✨ The color is so pretty and gives the eyes the perfect pop without feeling too much. I love how it instantly makes a simple eye look feel more fun and el...
M·A·C Kajal Excess Longwear Smoky Eye Liner
The perfect pop of yellow! 💛 It’s creamy, super pigmented, and glides onto the waterline so smoothly. It instantly brightens the whole eye look and stays vibrant without smudging. I’m obsessed! ✨
ColourPop Crème Gel Waterproof Eyeliner - Punch
Okay, this mascara really understood the assignment 😍 It gave my lashes instant length, lift, and buildable volume without looking clumpy or feeling heavy. The waterproof formula stayed put all day with no smudging, and the brush caught even my tini...
M·A·CStack Waterproof Mascara
That pop of periwinkle blue against a deep cherry eye? Obsessed with the contrast. 💙 The ColourPop BFF Crème Gel Liner in Prance has the kind of colour that makes a familiar makeup look feel fresh. What I love is the shade pairing. It stands out aga...
Prance BFF Crème Gel Liner - ColourPop | Ulta Beauty
Charmer is such a gorgeous deep plum liner. The color is rich, super pigmented, and glides on so smoothly without tugging. I especially love it on the waterline because it instantly makes a plum eye look feel deeper and more dramatic. 💜
Charmer | Crème Gel Liner
1
971 Plum is such a beautiful mascara shade. The deep plum gives the lashes noticeable color without looking too bright, and I love how much volume and definition it gives even with one coat. Perfect when I want something softer and more interesting t...
SEPHORA
Fig Smoulder with the Dior plum mascara is such a gorgeous combo. The liner gives the eyes that deep smoky plum definition, while the mascara pulls the whole look together without making it feel too dark. I love this pairing when I want a softer alte...
Rock N Kohl Quick Kajal Long-lasting Eyeliner Pencil: Fig Smoulder Matte Purple Eyeliner
Mascaras Worth Trying
For the days when black mascara feels too predictable. These are the colored mascaras I reach for to add subtle dimension and pull an entire eye look together.
This link is for 161 Overblue, an electric blue shade. Ulta describes it as intensely pigmented with extreme volume and lash by lash definition. Ulta Beauty Review: 161 Overblue is such a fun switch from black mascara. The blue actually shows up on t...
161 Overblue Diorshow Overvolume Extreme Volume Mascara - Dior | Ulta Beauty