Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

on a mission to find the best cookie in Chicago 🍪

Purple Star emoji 5 items
on a mission to find the best cookie in Chicago
 
Lexi F profile picture
so far at the top of my list - the coconut chunk from the Cookie Bar by Summer House. 10/10. It's the perfect mix of coconut and chocolate chips. I've gone back twice to get it and they still have it even though it was a limited edition to end a few ...
The Cookie Bar by Summer House
 
Lexi F profile picture
and it would definitely not be this from North Buena Deli. So many Google reviews said this was the best cookie in Chicago and it was far from it. Pieces of it were undercooked and not in a good way. I would definitely not even get this again. But th...
NORTH BUENA DELI (UPTOWN)
 
Lexi F profile picture
Not a cookie, but the best donuts I've ever had. They are made with potatoes and they just melt in your mouth. It almost tastes like you're eating a funnel cake, but better. Go early before they sell out for the day at Downstate Donuts.
Downstate Donuts
 
Lexi F profile picture
I've had Cloud Cookie on my list for years to try and I was finally able to. The cookies are SO fresh and soft. I'm not entirely sure where I'd rank these on my overall list just yet, but they are good. The white macadamia one is just a little too sw...
Cloud Cookie
 
Lexi F profile picture
they were sold out of the chocolate chip cookies, but this oatmeal pecan brittle cookie, pizza, and garlic knots were amazing! I can't wait to go back to Jimmy's Pizza Cafe and try the chocolate chip cookie one day.
Jimmy's Pizza Cafe