Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Better Than Starbucks: My Ultimate Dairy-Free PSL Recipe & The Best Milk Frother to Use

Purple Star emoji 21 items
Let's be honest: the craving for a Pumpkin Spice Latte is a powerful force. But the standard coffee shop version often leaves dairy-free individuals with limited, and sometimes lackluster, options. What if you could create a version at home that is n...
This recipe was born from a simple desire: a truly satisfying, creamy, and authentically spiced dairy-free PSL. After countless tests, the goal was clear—to achieve a perfect balance where the espresso shines through, the pumpkin flavor is present ...
Crafting the Ultimate Dairy-Free Pumpkin Spice Latte
The secret to a superior homemade PSL lies in using real ingredients and a proper frothing technique. This method gives you complete control over the sweetness and spice level.
The Core Components:
· For the Pumpkin Spice Mix: · 3 tablespoons canned pumpkin puree (not pie filling) · 1 tablespoon maple syrup (or adjust to taste) · 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract · 1/4 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice blend · A tiny pinch of fine sea salt...
The Step-by-Step Process:
1. Combine the Base: In a small saucepan or your mug, whisk together the pumpkin puree, maple syrup, vanilla extract, pumpkin pie spice, and salt until it forms a smooth paste. 2. Brew and Integrate: Pull your two shots of espresso directly into t...
Selecting Your Dairy-Free Milk
The choice of milk is critical. For the best froth and a neutral, creamy base, Oat Milk is the undisputed champion. Its natural starchiness creates a microfoam remarkably similar to dairy milk. Extra-Creamy Oat Milk or Barista Blend Almond Milk are...
The Essential Tool: Your Milk Frother
A quality frother is the key differentiator between a good homemade latte and a great one. While you can whisk by hand, a frother incorporates air to create that essential light, creamy texture.
For the ultimate convenience and results, a handheld electric frother is highly recommended. These battery-operated wands are affordable, easy to clean, and incredibly effective at transforming hot milk into a rich foam in seconds. Simply submerge ...
Taking the few minutes to prepare this recipe is more than a convenience—it’s an upgrade to your coffee experience. You gain the freedom to adjust the sweetness, control the spice, and enjoy a latte made with wholesome, recognizable ingredients. Wi...
Sections
3
 
 
 

Selecting Your Dairy-Free Milk

Navigating the world of dairy-free milk is a personal journey, but it doesn't have to be a guessing game. Each of these products excels in a specific area, whether it's creating the perfect foam, offering a nutritional boost, or delivering pure, crea...
 
Lisa white profile picture
This is the one I always keep on hand for coffee. It steams and froths with a microfoam so velvety and rich, it genuinely mimics whole dairy milk. Unlike some brands that can taste thin or oaty, Oatly Barista has a neutral, slightly sweet flavor that...
Oatly Barista Edition Oatmilk
 
Lisa white profile picture
When I'm watching my sugar intake but refuse to compromise on taste, this is my go-to. Its clean, nutty flavor is perfectly balanced without any beany aftertaste. I find it blends beautifully in smoothies and protein shakes without overpowering other...
Califia Farms Unsweetened Almond Milk 32oz x6
 
Lisa white profile picture
Silk created this with a specific goal: to replicate the taste and mouthfeel of dairy milk. And it works. The "Whole Fat" version has a richness that stands up powerfully to coffee's acidity. When I froth it, I get a thick, pillowy foam that holds it...
Silk Nextmilk Whole Fat Oat & Plant Milk
 
Lisa white profile picture
I use this specifically to add a tropical, creamy dimension to my smoothies and curries. Its light coconut essence transforms a simple fruit smoothie into a vacation-inspired treat without being overly sweet. While it's thinner and doesn't froth for ...
So Delicious Coconut Milk Unsweetened
 
Lisa white profile picture
As someone who has friends with nut and soy allergies, Ripple has been a game-changer. What amazes me is its nutritional profile—it’s packed with protein, making it a filling choice. The texture is wonderfully creamy and it has a very neutral, kid-fr...
Ripple Original Plant Based Milk, 8g Pea Protein
 
Lisa white profile picture
This is the classic that never fails. For decades, this has been the reliable, creamy soy milk that doesn't curdle in hot coffee—a major win. I appreciate its high protein content and the familiar, slightly beany taste that I’ve come to associate wit...
Silk Soy Milk
 
Lisa white profile picture
When I want to turn my coffee or tea into a decadent, silky treat, I reach for Elmhurst. It’s noticeably richer and creamier than almost any other shelf-stable option. Because they use a unique HydroRelease method, you get more nuts and less water in...
Elmhurst 1925 Cashew Milk Unsweetened 32oz 6pk

A Handheld Electric Frother

 
Lisa white profile picture
This was my first handheld frother, and it set a high standard. The powerful motor whips up a thick, creamy foam from oat milk in under 15 seconds. I specifically appreciate the sturdy, comfortable handle and the fact that it’s stood up to daily use ...
Zulay Kitchen Milk Frother Wand w/ 2 Duracell Batteries
 
Lisa white profile picture
The Powerlix stands out for its incredible battery life. A single charge seems to last for weeks, which means I never have the frustration of a dead battery mid-preparation. The frothing wand is just the right length for my deepest mugs, and it creat...
PowerLix Handheld Milk Frother with Stand
 
Lisa white profile picture
While most frothers are for mixing within your cup, this one has its own sleek, standalone pitcher. I use it when making two drinks at once for my partner and me. It has two settings—one for a warm, dense foam and another for a cool, light froth for ...
Instant Pot 4-in-1 Milk Frother 10oz
 
Lisa white profile picture
For its compact size, the Aervana packs a surprising punch. I keep one at my office because it’s so small and lightweight. It runs on AA batteries, which is perfect for a desk drawer. It effortlessly transforms my afternoon cup of tea with a little f...
Best products on Amazon's Amazon Page
 
Lisa white profile picture
This product is a two-in-one marvel. The magnetic base holds the frother upright, keeping my counter clean, and it comes with different whisk attachments. I use the flat whisk for frothing milk and the coil whisk for mixing protein shakes and hot cho...
Zulay Kitchen Original Frother Stainless Stand
 
Lisa white profile picture
The Epare feels exceptionally well-built and balanced in my hand. The stainless steel shaft is long and cleans easily. What I love most is the consistent, quiet power—it doesn’t sound strained, even with thicker, barista-style oat milk. It creates a ...
Eparé Handheld Electric Milk Frother
 
Lisa white profile picture
The Miroco strikes a perfect balance between elegant design and raw function. Its sleek, minimalist look is a nice addition to my kitchen, but the performance is what wins me over. It’s remarkably quiet and creates a super-silky foam that reminds me ...
Miroco Milk Frother

the core component pumpkin spice mix

The heart of any great pumpkin spice creation is, without a doubt, the blend itself. Whether you gravitate toward a trusted classic, an organic option, a complex artisanal mix, or a stellar value find, the right spice blend can transform simple ingre...
 
Lisa white profile picture
This is the classic, reliable blend I've used for years. The balance of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice is perfectly calibrated for that familiar, comforting flavor. I trust its consistency completely; I know that every time I open a new bottl...
McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice, 9 oz
 
Lisa white profile picture
For the avid baker, this larger bag is an incredible value. The flavor is robust and aromatic, with a noticeable brightness from the ginger. I love that I can be generous with it when making large batches of pumpkin bread or spiced cookies for holida...
The Spice Way Pumpkin Pie Spice 8 oz
 
Lisa white profile picture
When I want to ensure I'm using a high-quality, certified organic product, this is my go-to. The spices taste incredibly fresh and vibrant. I find the clove and allspice notes are particularly pronounced, giving my homemade PSL a more complex, deep f...
Simply Organic Pumpkin Pie Spice 0.46oz x6
 
Lisa white profile picture
This brand strikes a perfect balance between quality and affordability. The blend is warm and well-rounded, without any single spice overpowering the others. I specifically love using this for my morning oatmeal or stirring it into Greek yogurt, as i...
Frontier, Spice Pumpkin Pie, 1.72 Ounce
 
Lisa white profile picture
This blend feels like a step above the rest. It includes mace and cardamom in addition to the classic spices, which adds a wonderfully warm and slightly exotic depth. When I use this, my kitchen smells like a professional patisserie. It’s my secret i...
Pumpkin Pie Spice Seasoning Blend, 5.6 oz
 
Lisa white profile picture
The freshness of Penzeys spices is legendary, and this blend is no exception. The aroma that fills the room when I open the jar is intensely fragrant and inviting. I notice a superior quality in the Vietnamese cinnamon they use, which provides a swee...
Penzeys Pumpkin Pie Spice 2oz Jar
 
Lisa white profile picture
This is the ultimate budget champion that performs far above its price point. For a fraction of the cost of other brands, it delivers a solid, dependable pumpkin spice flavor. I keep a jar in my cupboard for everyday use—it’s perfect for those times ...
Pumpkin Pie Spice