Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 30 Arch Support Insoles So My Old Shoes Could Stop Hurting
30
items Standing all day at work left me limping by 5pm. Plantar fasciitis, flat feet, that burning heel pain that makes you dread putting shoes on in the morning. I cycled through about 30 different insoles over two years, wrecked a few pairs of shoes in th...
Sections
5
Insoles for Plantar Fasciitis Relief
Best Insoles for Standing All Day at Work
Cushioned Insoles for Everyday Walking Shoes
Athletic Insoles for Running and Sports
Specialty Insoles for Specific Foot Problems
Insoles for Plantar Fasciitis Relief
That stabbing heel pain when you first step out of bed? I lived with it for eight months before finding insoles that actually addressed it. These are the ones that let me walk to the kitchen without wincing.
Grab these if you're the person who hobbles around for the first ten minutes every morning. Within a week my heel pain dropped from a 7 to maybe a 2. They fit in most sneakers without making them tight.
Dr.Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Orthotics
Swapped these into my beat-up New Balances and they felt like shoes I just bought. The arch is firm, almost aggressive, but if you have flat feet that's exactly what you need. Took about three days to break in.
Superfeet All-Purpose Support High Arch Insoles (Green)
Use these if your podiatrist told you to get orthotics but you don't want to spend $400 on custom ones. A coworker recommended them and I genuinely forgot I had plantar fasciitis for a whole weekend.
Customer reviews for PowerStep Pinnacle Plus Orthotic
Keep a pair in your gym shoes. They're thinner than most arch supports so they don't crowd your toes. Ran a 5K in these after months of skipping runs because of heel pain.
Sof Sole Insoles Men's ATHLETE Performance Full-Length
Toss these in if you're on a budget and skeptical that a $15 insole can do anything. My sister bought them on a whim and then ordered three more pairs for every shoe she owns.
WalkHero Plantar Fasciitis Insoles for Men & Women
Try these specifically if you have low arches and other insoles feel like they're poking the wrong spot. The arch placement is slightly different and for my foot shape it hit perfectly where nothing else did.
Samurai Insoles Sumos- Super-Padded Orthotics for Flat
Best Insoles for Standing All Day at Work
I work retail, which means eight hours on concrete floors in shoes that were never designed for that. Before I found the right insoles I was soaking my feet in ice water every night like some kind of sad ritual.
Slip these in before a double shift. I went from counting down the hours to actually forgetting about my feet, which is honestly the highest compliment an insole can get.
Work Insoles with Massaging Gel
Pair these with any work boot. They have this cone-shaped cushioning thing that sounds gimmicky but my calves stopped cramping after long shifts. Worth every penny if you're on warehouse floors.
Timberland PRO Anti-Fatigue Technology Insole
Get these if you're a bigger person and other insoles flatten out after a month. I'm 220 lbs and these still had shape after four months of daily wear. Most insoles I tried were pancakes by week six.
Superfeet
Switch to these if your current insoles slide around inside your boots. They grip the footbed and stay put. Nothing worse than an insole bunching up mid-shift when you can't stop to fix it.
KEEN Women's K-20 Outdoor Plus Insole, Black, M
Snag these for shoes that run a little loose. They add just enough volume without making things cramped. A nurse friend of mine swears by them for 12-hour hospital shifts.
Insoles
Bring these if you work outdoors in cold weather. They insulate surprisingly well and the arch support is solid without being rock hard. My feet stayed warm through a full winter on a construction site.
Carhartt Insite Technology Footbed CMI9000 Insole
Cushioned Insoles for Everyday Walking Shoes
Not every insole needs to feel like a medical device. Sometimes you just want your sneakers or casual shoes to stop feeling like cardboard after a year of wear.
Toss these in any pair of shoes that lost their cushion. They're the reason I didn't throw out my favorite Vans. Feels like walking on something that actually wants you there.
Dr. Scholl's Comfort & Energy Massaging Gel Insoles
Use these in your daily walkers if you log a lot of steps. I average about 10,000 a day and these kept my arches from collapsing by evening. The heel cup is deep enough to actually hold your foot in place.
Spenco Total Support Max Shoe Insoles
Swap your factory insoles for these in any flat shoe. They're thin enough for dress shoes but still add real arch support. Wore them to a wedding and danced for three hours without regretting it.
New Balance Casual Memory Top Insole
Try these if you need arch support in women's flats or heels. Most insoles are way too thick for anything that isn't a sneaker. These are the only ones that fit in my ballet flats without my heel popping out.
PowerStep SlenderFit 3/4 Arch Support Shoe Inserts
Grab a pair for those old shoes sitting in your closet that you love but can't wear anymore. The memory foam molds to your foot shape within a couple hours. Brought my favorite boots back from the dead.
Sof Sole Memory Plus Full Length Shoe Insoles
Perfect if you're someone who wears pointed-toe shoes and thinks arch support is impossible. They're ¾ length so they don't bunch up at the toe. Finally wore my nice shoes to work without paying for it later.
Dr. Scholls Stylish Step Hidden Arch Support for Flats
Athletic Insoles for Running and Sports
Running on worn-out insoles gave me shin splints that took months to heal. That was an expensive lesson. Now I rotate insoles the way serious runners rotate shoes.
Ditch your factory running shoe insoles for these. My stride felt more stable within the first mile and that nagging knee twinge I'd been ignoring just stopped. Wish someone had told me sooner.
Superfeet
Use these if you pronate and your ankles roll inward when you run. They come in different arch heights so you actually pick the right one instead of guessing. My physical therapist recommended them.
How Long Do CURREX Insoles Last?
Snag these for cross-training days. They handle lateral movement way better than most running-specific insoles. Stopped getting that burning feeling on the ball of my foot during HIIT classes.
Spenco - Ironman Train Insole
Get these if you get pain in the ball of your foot. The metatarsal pad redistributes pressure and it's the only insole that let me run more than three miles without that sharp forefoot sting.
Powerstep PULSE Plus Orthotic Running Shoe Insoles
Try these in hiking boots or trail runners. They mold to your foot with body heat, kind of like a semi-custom fit. Did a 14-mile hike and my feet felt better at the end than the beginning, which makes no sense but happened.
SOLE Active Thick Shoe Insoles - Multiple Sizes
Keep a pair as your backup. They're affordable enough that you can replace them every couple months without thinking twice. Not the fanciest option but they're reliable and I've bought them probably six times now.
Dr. Scholl's Athletic Series Running Insoles for Women
Specialty Insoles for Specific Foot Problems
Some foot issues need more than generic cushioning. High arches, supination, metatarsalgia. If you've been told you have a “weird foot” by a shoe salesperson, this section is for you.
Try these if every insole you've bought feels flat under your arch. High arches are weirdly underserved and most “arch support” insoles barely reach. These actually fill the gap and my feet stopped aching after long walks.
Customer reviews for PowerStep Pinnacle High Arch
Grab these for anyone with diabetes or neuropathy who needs cushioning without pressure points. Bought them for my dad after his doctor said regular insoles were too firm. He wears them in everything now.
Spenco Medics Diabetic+ Insole
Use these as your starter insole if you've never tried arch support before. The arch isn't too aggressive so it won't shock your feet. Think of it as training wheels before you move to something firmer.
Are superfeet insoles worth the cost? : r/backpacking
Swap these into dress shoes or leather boots. They're made of actual leather so they breathe and don't make your feet sweat like foam insoles do. Wore them in oxfords all summer and no blisters.
pedag® VIVA® Semi-Rigid Orthotic Insole Metatarsal
Perfect if you're someone with wide feet who finds most insoles too narrow. The air chambers in the heel absorb shock without adding bulk. Finally found something that fits my size 12 wide shoes properly.
Sof Sole Airr Orthotic Full Length Shoe Insoles
Get these if you love the feel of Birkenstocks but want that contoured footbed in all your shoes. The cork and latex combo is firmer than foam but way more supportive. Took about a week to break in, then I never looked back.
Birkenstock Sport Blue Footbed Arch Support Insoles