This is really about a preference, but I use a dark brown lip liner. That’s kind of close to your black.
Slim Lip Pencil Creamy Lip Liner | NYX Professional Makeup
I use the coffee bean lip liner. This is a dark brown, and it is waterproof.
The Coffee Shop Luxe Lip Liner
I use crème brûlée butter close after I apply lip liner. I put it in between my lip liner and not on top if that makes sense. Then you can just go in with your favorite lip gloss to put on top of it.
Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss | NYX Professional Makeup
