NYC is home to some of the most indulgent, texture-obsessed cookies you’ll ever try—and this list rounds up the very best. From giant melty-center chocolate chip monsters to delicate classics, vegan treats, late-night wins, and flavor experiments, Annie’s picks span the sweet spectrum. Whether you’re hunting for that perfect crisp edge with a gooey inside or a black-and-white you’ll never forget, these cookies are worth the crumb trail through the city.