Call my old school, but this is still my go to eye liner. I just haven't found one I love more. I have drawer full of different ones, but I always repurchase this.
Espresso Perfect Point Plus Eye Pencil - CoverGirl | Ulta Beauty
I was influenced to try this one, and immediately loved it. Stopped buying the more expensive brow pencil immediately
Black Brown Express Brow Ultra Slim Pencil - Maybelline | Ulta Beauty
I've been using this for a setting powder recently. Not exactly what I was hoping, but decent enough to set my concealer