Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
discover Discover

SHELBY ANN 2026 DRUGSTORE MAKEUP ROUTINE
Purple Star emoji 19 items
By
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
Nicole Sherrill
this list is for my husband so he knows what i want for mothers day / birthday / Christmas / etc :-))
Sections
4
 
SKIN PREP
 
BROWS, EYES, & LASHES
 
FACE
 
LIPPIE:-)

SKIN PREP

gotta be able to ice skate on the skin before you move into makeup ;-)

 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
for her skin prep! she has sworn by this in both 2025 and 2026 routines
Milky Hydrating Face Toner with Snow Mushroom and Hyaluronic Acid - Thayers | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
in 2025 she used the ELF thirst burst drops but she no longer supports ELF and uses this goodie from Bubble
Water Slide Hydration Boosting Serum Hyaluronic Acid + Peptides - Bubble | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
This is the alternative for the Bubble waterslide
Phyto Mucin Glow Serum - BYOMA | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
very lightweight sunscreen with high coverage for daily wear
Ultra-Lightweight Face Fluid SPF 50 - BYOMA | Ulta Beauty
placeholder

BROWS, EYES, & LASHES

to elevate the eye area

 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
tried & true brow gel from L'oreal
Infallible Up to 24H Brow Lamination - L'Oréal | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
for precise brows
MCoBeauty XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Light/Medium - 0.004oz: Vegan, Eyebrow Enhancer, Single Container
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
eye shadow palette for $13 what a steal !!
The Master Icon The Icon Palette - Revolution Beauty | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
mascara of choice
Blackest Black Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara - Maybelline | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
mentioned as a more affordable mascara (half the price of Maybelline)
Black Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara - Essence | Ulta Beauty
placeholder

FACE

perfect skin would be ideal but since i can't have that… <3

 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
two years in a row!! her fav foundation
N3 Neutral Light Medium True Match Super-Blendable Foundation - L'Oréal | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
i already have this and love it:-)
Hey Honey Cheek Kiss Cream Bronzer - Milani | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
i already have a few shades of this but would loooove it in pink sprinkle !!
Pink Sprinkle Trublend Skin Enhancer Balm Blush Stick - CoverGirl | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
this concealer looks incredible !! and half the price of my Neutrogena i purchased in 2025 after watching her videos hahah
120 Silky Blur Hydrating Longwear Concealer - Essence | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
a pinky setting powder for under the eyes will seemingly make it look like i have slept!! yay
Brightening Light Pink Infallible Blur-Fection Longwear Loose Setting Powder - L'Oréal | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
this has replaced her Loreal powder bronzer
Caramel Truffle TruBlend Skin Enhancer Baked Luminous Bronzer - CoverGirl | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
the blush mentioned but it is almost twenty dollars :-(
10 Confident Pink Infallible 24H Fresh Wear Soft Matte Blush - L'Oréal | Ulta Beauty
placeholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
“glycerin rich” setting spray before lips !!
Hard Candy Glow On Lock Setting Spray, Alcohol-Free, 16 Hour Hold, Luminous Finish
placeholder

LIPPIE:-)

and finally! lips!

 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
this is what she used in the video but mentioned she doesn't ALWAYS reach for it because it is a plumper so it is spicy
Ducking Clear Duck Plump Retractable Plumping Lip Liner - NYX Professional Makeup | Ulta Beauty
placeholderplaceholder
 
Nicole Sherrill profile picture
she tops off her lip combo with this
Ice Lifter Gloss with Hyaluronic Acid - Maybelline | Ulta Beauty
placeholder