Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Mystery Boxes
22
items I love a good mystery box and have tried a lot of different companies. This list contains all of my favorites!
Follow me on socials to see what’s inside
TT: RaeBarrett515
FB: Midwest Pallet Fun
Sections
4
Amazon Mystery Boxes
Keeper Boxes
Just for Fun
For Resell
Amazon Mystery Boxes
These companies offer Amazon Mystery Boxes.
Amazon Mystery Boxes: J&O Mystery Box purchases pallets of Amazon Boxes and resells them indivually. They offer a discount for purchasing multiple boxes. You pay for the box plus shipping.
J&O Mystery Box
Amazon Mystery Boxes: Bargain Brothers has recently started offering Amazon Mystery Boxes online for delivery. Local customers can either schedule a delivery through DoorDash or pick up a box in person for $50. For customers who prefer shipping, they...
Bargain Brothers
Reseller Amazon Mystery Box Pallets: Continental Wholesale is my preferred source for Amazon Mystery Box pallets because of their convenient location, allowing me to pick up orders in person and avoid shipping costs. They specialize in pallet sales o...
Continental Wholesale LLC
Amazon Mystery Boxes: Detroit Pallet Liquidation offers Amazon Mystery Boxes that can be conveniently shipped directly to your door. Each box is priced at $50, with applicable tax and shipping costs added at checkout. You can find them on Facebook to...
Detroit Pallet Liquidation
Amazon Mystery Boxes: Resellables is in Massachusetts which is likely the best option for those of you on the east coast. They sell boxes for $55 plus shipping.
Resellables
Amazon Mystery Boxes: GRP Liquidation offers Amazon Mystery Boxes. The boxes are $69.99 and you pay tax and shipping on top of that.
GRP Liquidations
Keeper Boxes
These are boxes that I love but don't necessarily think they hold a enough retail value to recommend then for resellers. But, you get usable items that are great for keeping or gifting to others.
Keeper or Reseller Box - J&O offers both Amazon Mystery Boxes designed for resale and curated boxes sourced from their liquidation purchases. Their boxes are well-organized, and I have never received broken items. They provide several sizes of ge...
J&O Mystery Box
Keepers Box: Pretty Packed Box offers excellent mystery boxes filled with brand-new items, perfect for personal use or gifting. The contents are ideal for gifts, stocking stuffers, or prizes, especially with the upcoming holidays. They have also rece...
Pretty Packed Box
Keepers Box: KK Wholesale offers high-quality mystery boxes filled with items that are perfect for keeping or gifting. My personal favorites are the Deluxe Home & Kitchen Box and the Target Mystery Boxes, both of which include a variety of practi...
KK Wholesale
Keeper Box -I’ve only ordered one box from [Company Name] so far, and it was fantastic. It included several pieces of jewelry and a wide variety of items across home goods and kitchen appliances (including an air fryer), pets, apparel, accessories, s...
The Bee Hive Mystery Box
Gift Giving; These mystery boxes are perfect for gift giving, offering nearly 200 themed options for both kids and adults. Each box includes 5–8 officially licensed items tailored to the selected theme, making them an excellent choice for Christmas o...
Stylin Boxes
Just for Fun
These boxes continue Mystery Mail which is super fun. It can be valuable but there is no guarantee so I only recommend these if you just want to have a good time. They are great for family and friend parties. Full of good laughs and a good time.
Just for Fun: The Party Box from Fun Delivered is my favorite mail-based mystery box. The variety of packages included is impressive, and I have consistently been able to make back my investment by reselling the items. I don’t typically recommend und...
Fundelivered
Just for fun: BupBoxes mystery boxes are filled with undelivered and unclaimed mail, return items, and overstock packages — all individually wrapped to create a fun surprise experience. The boxes are generously packed, and you can even watch your ord...
BupBoxes
Reseller & Just for fun: GRP Liquidations offers one of the widest selections of mystery boxes I’ve seen, including options for mail, jewelry, clothing, overstock, and many other unique themes. I recommend joining their email list — they notify s...
GRP Liquidations
This is a new female owned company out of Texas. The boxes contain a mix of overstock, unclaimed mail and returns. There are 3 different sizes of boxes ranging from $140-$220 with no additional shipping included.
BigFNBox
Just for Fun: The Mystery Box Co has a couple different sized Mystery Mail Boxes that contain unclaimed mail, returns and overstock like the other companies. Everything comes wrapped and it's a fun surprise to see what's inside. The boxes are $119.99...
The Mystery Box Co
Just for Fun: The Mystery Chicks is a newer player in the mystery box market. I was gifted a box from them to review, and while it was decent, it primarily contained Temu returns. I’ve seen others receive better selections, so results may vary. Their...
MysteryChick
For Resell
These are companies who I buy from who's boxes have the most resell potential, in my opinion.
Reseller Pallets: Continental Wholesale only sells pallets but they do ship. They offer a few options for single pallets but also sell some by the truckload or half truckload. Ask for Adam and tell him I sent you. He is as honest as they come.
Continental Wholesale LLC
Reseller Box: USA Mystery Boxes offers mystery boxes filled with e-commerce returns at very competitive pricing. In addition to individual boxes, they have recently begun offering pallets of untouched, unfiltered Amazon merchandise. Because these are...
USA MYSTERY BOX
Keep or Resell Box:I ordered the Medium Mystery Box for $200, and the total retail value of the contents exceeded $800. Every item was brand new and sourced from department stores, including high-end clothing, electronics, toys, beauty products, and ...
K Cargo
Reseller Box: UpLiquidation curates mystery boxes specifically designed for resellers. They offer several options, including an E-Com Box, a Jumbo Kids Mystery Box, and a variety of clothing mystery boxes. While I have had strong success with many of...
UpLiquidation
Just for Fun or Reseller: Although I have not personally purchased from Nellis Auction because they do not offer delivery and I do not live near one of their locations, a close Mystery Box friend of mine shops there regularly and consistently finds e...
Nellis Auction