I have been to so many vintage stores & thrift stores on Long Island and each one is good for different things - use the map feature to scroll that way or sort by Vintage VS Thrift! Happy Hunting!
Map
Sections
2
Vintage Stores & Antiques
Thrift Stores
Vintage Stores & Antiques
Where to shop for curated vintage.
A must visit if you're on the south shore! Nautical, mid century home decor, clothing, and more!
Sea City Vintage
Great clothing selection! Located in Wantagh.
Dino-Mite Vintage
Great selection of vintage clothes and jewelry!
TT'sclosettt
Antique mall with multiple vendors! I've had luck with records, home decor, and clothes here!
Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center
Great vintage in an awesome old building! 10/10 vibes.
Rosie's Vintage
Nina a.k.a. The Thriftocrat curates beautiful high end vintage home decor for your chicest friend!
Royal Native
Farmhouse vibes, but make it rustic chic and vintage.
LUMBER+Salt
Cute little spot for clothing. Some homewares downstairs!
The Junior League of Long Island Thrift Shop
High end furniture consignment. Incredible home finds!
Valley attic
A little bit of everything! Definitely worth a visit!
wit & whim
Pyrex, mid century home finds, and so much more!
Antique Attics
Thrift Stores
Giving all my secrets away!!!
Small, but good home finds and sometimes clothing.
American Thrift Stores - Baldwin
HUGE warehouse! Mostly clothing.
American Thrift Store - Farmingville
My go-to spot! Good clothing finds.
Island Thrift
Home finds! And clothes are hit or miss but there's lots of options.
MyUnique Thrift
Good clothing finds, not so much home at this spot!
Savers
Only open Sundays, but lots of good finds here - especially a hidden gem for records!
The Antique & Thrift Shop
I once found a pair of Moon Boots here!! Hit or miss clothing finds.
