Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Finally Got Vibrant Frosting Colors Without Turning It Into Soup
44
items Spent years squeezing those little liquid bottles into buttercream and watching it turn into a runny mess — the colors were always dull and the consistency was ruined. If you decorate cakes even occasionally and you're tired of pastel-when-you-wanted...
Sections
11
Gel Food Coloring Sets That Actually Deliver Bold Color
Individual Gel Colors for When You Need That One Exact Shade
Buttercream Recipes That Hold Up to Gel Coloring
Piping Tips That Show Off Your Vibrant Colors
Piping Bags and Couplers That Don't Explode Mid-Squeeze
Mixing Tools for Even Color Distribution
Gel Food Coloring Sets That Actually Deliver Bold Color
Liquid food coloring was my nemesis for years — I'd dump half a bottle in and still end up with baby pink instead of red. These gels changed everything with just a tiny dot.
Grab this set first — a toothpick swirl of the red gave me a deeper crimson than an entire bottle of liquid ever did. Perfect for anyone just starting to decorate.
Wilton Edible Gel Food Coloring Set, 12-pack of 0.5 Oz jars
Switch to these if you want colors so saturated your friends accuse you of using fondant. Barely need any product so one set lasted me over a year of weekend baking.
AmeriColor, Student Kit , 12 .75 Ounce Food Color Bottles
Use these when you need to color a huge batch — they blend into buttercream without changing the texture at all. Saved me right before my daughter's unicorn cake party.
LIQUA-GEL 12 Color Kit Food Coloring
Snag this smaller set if you don't need twelve colors sitting in your drawer. The black is genuinely black, not that weird charcoal gray most brands give you.
Ann Clark, Gel Food Coloring Set, 0.70 oz, Multicolor
Individual Gel Colors for When You Need That One Exact Shade
Nothing worse than buying a whole set because you ran out of red three days before a party. These singles have rescued me more than once.
Keep this stocked because you will run out of pink-family colors faster than anything else — baby showers, Valentine's Day, it goes quick.
Wilton Rose Food Coloring Edible Gel for Baking & Cake
Try this specific red if regular red gel keeps giving you that orangey tomato shade. One drop and my Red Velvet cake topping finally looked the part.
AmeriColor, Soft Gel Paste Food Color, Super Red 4.5 oz
Get the bigger bottle — black eats through product like nothing else. Learned that the hard way making a Halloween cake with the tiny jar and running out halfway through.
BLACK ICING COLOR WILTON 1 OZ
Pair this with a tiny bit of purple for a navy that actually looks navy. For anyone who's ever tried to make a blue cake and ended up with something resembling a Smurf.
Chefmaster Royal Blue Liqua-Gel Food Color
Buttercream Recipes That Hold Up to Gel Coloring
Even the best gel coloring can't save a weak buttercream. I ruined batches until I nailed down recipes that stay stiff even when tinted.
Toss this in a bowl and add gel color when you're short on time — it holds pigment way better than the store-brand versions I tried first.
Betty Crocker, Frosting, 16 oz, Rich and Creamy Vanilla
Use this as your lazy Sunday base — it's thick enough that even three colors swirled together didn't make it slide off my cupcakes.
Pillsbury, Creamy Supreme Vanilla Frosting, 16 oz Tub
Grab a couple cans for backup because this one takes gel color without getting grainy. My go-to when I'm making 48 cupcakes for school events.
Duncan Hines, Creamy Vanilla Frosting, 16 oz, Ready-to-use
Switch to this when you need colors on sculpted pieces — gel colors knead right in without making it sticky. Took me three failed fondant attempts before someone told me about this one.
Wilton Premade White Fondant, Vanilla Flavored
Piping Tips That Show Off Your Vibrant Colors
What's the point of perfect color if your piping looks like a kindergartner did it? These tips made me look like I knew what I was doing.
Grab this instead of buying tips one at a time — the star tips especially make two-toned frosting look incredible when you load colors side by side.
Wilton Open Star Decorating Tip 14
Try this for rosettes that show off color gradients — the ridges catch light differently and make a single color look three-dimensional. My most-used tip honestly.
Ateco # 869 - French Star Pastry Tip .69'' Opening Diameter
Use this one for those swirly cupcake tops you see on Instagram. Even my first attempt looked decent and the color really pops in the grooves.
(4 pack) Wilton Open Star Cake Decorating Tip 1M
Snag this for anyone who wants impressive-looking flowers with zero skill. One squeeze and twist — that's it. The vibrant gel colors make each petal pop.
Wilton No. 1 E Drop Flower Tip
Piping Bags and Couplers That Don't Explode Mid-Squeeze
Had a bag burst on me during my sister's baby shower. Bright purple buttercream everywhere — on the ceiling, on the dog. Never again.
Keep a whole pack in your drawer because you'll burn through them fast when you're doing multiple colors. Thick enough that I've never had one burst since switching.
Wilton 12 inch Disposable Decorating Piping Bags
Get the bigger size when you're frosting a full sheet cake — less refilling means your arm doesn't give out halfway through. Learned this during a marathon decorating session.
Wilton, Disposable Decorating Piping Bags
Use couplers so you can swap tips without emptying the bag — saved me twenty minutes on my last cake when I changed my mind about the border design.
Ateco 3-Piece Medium Pastry Bag Coupler Set, Plastic
Toss these on when you need to pause mid-project. Before I had these I'd come back to dried-out crusty tips and have to start over.
Wilton Silicone Cake Decorating Frosting Tip Cover Set
Mixing Tools for Even Color Distribution
Streaky frosting haunted me until I realized my spatula was the problem. Proper mixing tools mean the color is consistent from first swipe to last.
Worth every penny if you're mixing buttercream more than once a month. Getting gel color evenly distributed by hand was giving me a forearm workout I didn't ask for.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Swap your old wooden spoon for this — the flat edge scrapes the sides of the bowl so you don't end up with white streaks hiding in your red frosting.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Spatula - White
Grab the angled one specifically — trying to smooth frosting with a straight spatula is like trying to paint a wall with a ruler. This changed my cake sides completely.
Wilton, Angled Icing Spatula, 9-inch, Black & Silver
Use this attachment if you already have a KitchenAid — it scrapes the bowl while mixing so every bit of gel color gets incorporated. No more stopping to scrape manually.
Tilt-Head Flex Edge Beater
Turntables and Stands for Smooth Application
Tried decorating a cake on a dinner plate once. Spun it, plate slid off the counter, cake hit the floor. A proper turntable costs less than remaking a whole cake.
Get this before your next cake project — being able to spin smoothly while holding the spatula steady is the difference between professional-looking and lopsided.
Wilton Trim-N-Turn Ultra Cake Decorating Turntable
Snag the heavier version if your cakes tend to be multi-tier. The lightweight ones wobble when you're working with anything over two layers.
Ateco Revolving Cake Stand - Aluminum
Use this to move your finished cake without leaving fingerprints in your perfect frosting. Destroyed too many cakes with the two-spatula method before finding this.
Wilton Cake Lifter
Keep a stack of these — they give your cake a clean base and make it way easier to transport. For anyone who's ever shown up to a party with frosting on their car seat.
Wilton 8-Inch Round Cake Boards, 11-Count
Color Mixing Guides and Inspiration
Spent way too long guessing how much blue plus yellow equals the green I actually wanted. These resources stopped the guesswork.
Try this system if you're the type who needs exact measurements — it comes with a chart so you can recreate the same teal every single time instead of eyeballing it.
Wilton Color Right Performance Food Coloring Set
Grab a copy and skip to the frosting chapters — her ratios for buttercream are bulletproof and she explains why certain frostings take color better than others.
Pre-Owned The Cake Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum
Perfect for someone who just got into cake decorating and feels overwhelmed. Comes with practice boards so you can mess up without wasting a whole cake.
Wilton Decorating Essentials Kit, 33-Piece
Keep this on your counter — her buttercream recipe on page 289 is the one I always come back to because it's stiff enough to hold any gel color without thinning.
Sally McKenney, Baking Book, 101 Recipes, Hardcover
Storage Solutions So Your Colors Don't Dry Out
Found a $9 gel color dried into a solid rock because I left it in a drawer for six months. Proper storage actually matters with these.
Toss all your gel colors in one of these so they stay upright and you can actually find the color you need without digging through a junk drawer.
Customer reviews for Sterilite Small Clip Box Storage Box
Use this for your most-used colors — the seal is tight enough that nothing dries out even if you only bake once a month.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container
Grab a bigger one if your collection has grown out of control like mine did. Fits gel colors, tips, couplers, and bags all in one spot.
Mainstays 28 Qt Underbed Plastic Storage Bins with Lids
Pour leftover tinted frosting into these and freeze them — pull one out next time you need that exact shade and save yourself thirty minutes of remixing.
Ball, Mason Jar, Quilted Crystal, Regular Mouth
Practice Surfaces and Tools for Color Testing
Mixing a color directly into a full batch and hoping for the best is gambling. Now I always test on a small amount first.
Use this to test your piped colors before committing to the real cake — way better than piping test swirls onto a paper towel like I used to do.
Wilton W4061075 Decorate Smart Deluxe Practice Board Set
Tear off a sheet and pipe test swirls onto it — you can see exactly how the color looks against white and it peels right off for cleanup.
Glad Press'N Seal Multipurpose Food Wrap, Clear
Keep a roll near your decorating station for quick color tests. Squeeze a dot of tinted frosting out and let it sit five minutes — some colors darken as they dry.
Reynolds Cut-Rite Wax Paper, 75 Square Feet
Scoop a small amount of white frosting into this, add your gel, and mix to test the shade before you commit to the whole bowl. Saved me from making a full batch of ugly green once.
Pyrex, Measuring Cup, 1 Cup, Easy-Read Marks, Clear
Cleanup Supplies Because Gel Color Stains Everything
My white countertop has a permanent pink shadow from the Great Frosting Disaster of 2022. Don't be me — have cleanup supplies ready.
Keep these under the sink because gel food coloring on a white counter will haunt you for weeks without one. Learned this after a bright blue incident that stressed me out for days.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Sponge, All Purpose Cleaner
Pair this with hot water immediately after a spill — the longer gel color sits on a surface the harder it is to remove. Ask my cutting board.
Dawn Platinum Dish Soap and Powerwash
Grab these for quick swipes between color changes so you don't accidentally mix red into your yellow. For anyone whose workspace looks like a crime scene after decorating.
Clorox, Disinfecting Wipes, 75ct, Crisp Lemon and Fresh
Wear these unless you want to show up to work Monday with purple fingers. Took me embarrassingly long to figure this out — my coworkers thought I had a bruising problem.
Nitrile Disposable Gloves