Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Party Favor Bags I Fill So Every Kid Actually Wants to Keep Them
49
items You know that sinking feeling when you hand out goodie bags and half the kids toss them in the car without looking? I spent way too many birthdays watching that happen. After throwing about nine parties between my two kids, I finally cracked the code...
Sections
7
Party Favor Bags That Don't Rip or Look Cheap
Small Toys That Don't End Up in the Trash
Candy That Disappears Before They Leave the Party
Fillers That Make Bags Look Stuffed Without Spending Much
Themed Favor Ideas for Specific Party Styles
Practical Favors Parents Won't Secretly Throw Away
Party Favor Bags That Don't Rip or Look Cheap
I used to grab the thinnest dollar bags and watch them tear before kids even made it to the car. These actually hold up and look like you tried.
Grab these for a crowd. I used them for a 25-kid party and still had extras. Bright colors, no kid complained about getting the ‘wrong’ one.
Multicolor Polka Dot Treat Bags with Twist Ties, 5" x 3" x 11
Toss these at a tween party and watch the giggles. My daughter's friends were fighting over which emoji face they got, which honestly was half the entertainment.
Unique Industries Gold Solid Print Birthday Party Bags
Use these when you want something that looks pulled together but you literally assembled everything 20 minutes before guests arrived. Nobody has to know.
12Pcs Polka dot gift bag Small Party Gift Bags For Birthday
Keep a stash of these in your craft drawer. Plain enough to customize with stickers, sturdy enough that the bottom won't blow out when you stuff them with candy.
Brown Premium Kraft Paper Bags, 16 in x 6 in x 12 in, 100 ct
Swap to these if you want kids to see what's inside before they open it. The clear bags actually make the whole thing look more exciting, weirdly.
Creative Converting Cello Bag, Lg Yellow, 20ct, 11.25" x 5"
Perfect for anyone throwing a glow party or a neon theme. My son's friends kept using them as puppet bags, which was not the plan but still a win.
Medium Neon Gift Bags - Party Supplies - 12 Pieces
Try these for a quick fill-and-tie situation. Twist tie closure means no fumbling with tape at 11pm the night before the party. Ask me how I know.
Balloons & Rainbow Birthday Cellophane Bags, 5" x 11", 20ct
Small Toys That Don't End Up in the Trash
Most party favor toys get played with for 30 seconds and forgotten. These are the ones I've seen kids actually bring to school the next week.
Get the mini size, not the full rainbow ones. They fit perfectly in bags and every kid at my daughter's party was walking around bouncing them down the stairs for an hour.
Fun Express Mini Christmas Magic Springs - 12 Pieces
Pair these with a small coloring sheet and suddenly you have an activity, not just filler. Parents texted me after saying their kids colored the whole car ride home.
12 Boxes Crayola 4-ct Crayon Party Pack
Snag these early because they sell out before birthday season. Each tub is the perfect grab-and-go size and no parent has ever been mad about Play-Doh showing up.
Play-Doh Bag, Party Favors, 15-Pack, 1 oz
Dump a handful in each bag and let chaos reign. My nephew covered his entire water bottle in these within five minutes of getting home. No regrets.
SmileMakers Stickers Assorted Colors 1000/Box LI10-R
Toss one in each bag for a mixed-gender party. I've never met a kid under 8 who turned down a Hot Wheels car, and at this price point you can do the whole guest list.
Hot Wheels Basic 1:64 Car 72-Piece H Assortment
Use these for the 6-and-up crowd. They're just tricky enough to keep kids busy during cake time, which honestly buys you 10 minutes of peace.
Multi-Color Children Mini Puzzle Cube Party Favors
Fair warning, these will end up stuck to your ceiling. But kids go absolutely feral for them, so just accept the chaos and let it happen.
Ja-Ru, Jumbo Giant Sticky Hand, N-414-8
Candy That Disappears Before They Leave the Party
Half the battle is picking candy that doesn't melt, doesn't have a million allergens, and actually tastes good. These cleared every test.
Grab the big bag so you can throw three or four in each favor bag. They don't melt in summer heat either, which saved me at an outdoor party last July.
Air Heads Mini Bars Variety Pack 80Ct
Pour a pack on top of the toys and the bag instantly looks full and colorful. Kids see Skittles and their whole face changes. Works every single time.
SKITTLES, Halloween Fun Size Fruity Candy Packs
Keep these on hand for nut-free parties. They're safe for most allergy kids and the giant bag means you'll have leftovers for Halloween too.
Smarties Original Candy Rolls, 1 lb
Stuff a few of these in the bottom of each bag as filler. They're small enough to pack tight and literally every generation of kid has liked these since forever.
Tootsie Roll Midgees Chocolate Candy, 43.1 Oz (400 Pieces)
Try the individually wrapped packs so everything stays fresh. One mom told me her kid ate three bags on the way home and asked when the next party was.
HARIBO, Gummy Bears, Goldbears, 22.8 oz
Stick two or three lollipops in each bag for that classic party look. The 300 count seems wild but trust me, you'll use them across multiple events.
Wholesale Spangler Dum Dum Pops 300CT (Pack of 3)
Wear your candy? Every kid thinks this is the greatest invention ever. My daughter's entire friend group wore them through the whole party like engagement rings.
Ring Pop, Individually Wrapped Lollipop, 40 Count
Fillers That Make Bags Look Stuffed Without Spending Much
Nobody wants to spend $15 per bag. These little extras cost almost nothing but make the whole thing feel generous.
Toss a pinch of this at the bottom of each bag before you add anything. Instant volume, instant color, and it takes about four seconds per bag.
Way To Celebrate White Paper Shred, 1.25 oz
Throw two or three in each bag. Kids treat these like actual treasure. My son's friend showed up to school Monday with a full sleeve of dinosaur tattoos from our party.
Shop Best Sellers Temporary Tattoos
Perfect if you're filling bags for a preschool crowd. They stamp everything in sight, including your walls, but the joy on their faces is worth the Mr. Clean later.
Fun Express Self-Inking Bright Color Plastic Stampers
Pull these apart and drop one in each bag. They work on paper, cardboard, even rocks. Parents actually appreciate this one because it's a real art supply, not junk.
Crayola Washable Fine Line Markers 10 Ct for Kids
Use this to tie off cellophane bags and suddenly your 5-minute assembly job looks like you hired a party planner. Fake it till you make it.
Way To Celebrate Curling Ribbon, Silver, 350 yds
Shaped like animals or food, these are the things kids hoard in their pencil cases all year. My daughter still has a pizza eraser from a party two years ago.
Animal Erasers for Office Supplies
Bring these out for outdoor parties especially. Kids blow bubbles on the walk to the car and it makes for accidentally great photos if you're paying attention.
Fun Express 2" .6 oz. Bulk 48 Pieces Mini Bright Color
Themed Favor Ideas for Specific Party Styles
When you pick a party theme, the favor bags should match or the whole vibe falls apart. Learned that one the hard way at a pirate party with princess bags.
Drop one of these in each bag for a dino party and watch the kids stomp around roaring. My son lined his up on the windowsill and they stayed there for months.
Unique Industries Assorted Neon Plastic Dinosaur Party
Pair these with some lip gloss and stickers for a princess theme. Every kid put theirs on immediately and refused to take it off, including the birthday girl's older brother.
48 Count, Pink/Purple Dress-Up Party Favors Pack, Includes
Slip one in each bag and you've got a room full of tiny superheroes running around screaming. It doubles as a party activity before cake, which is a nice bonus.
Marvel Avengers Birthday Party Masks, One Size, 8ct
Use these for a space or science party. The galaxy print is cool enough that older kids don't feel like it's babyish, which is a tough line to walk at age 9.
Creative Converting Soccer Favor Bags, 8 ct
Perfect for a sports-themed party. These bounce way higher than you'd expect, so maybe hand them out at the end unless you want chaos during the party itself.
Way To Celebrate Multi-Color Sticky Bounce Ball Party
Get this pack for a mermaid or ocean party. It covers multiple bag fillers in one purchase, which means fewer late-night shopping trips for you.
120Pcs Ocean Party Favors Set, Under The Sea Birthday
Fill these with candy for a construction theme and kids think it's the coolest thing ever. They're basically tiny traffic cones that double as treat holders.
Way To Celebrate Disposable Plastic Cups, Blue, 8.79 fl oz
Practical Favors Parents Won't Secretly Throw Away
Real talk. Half of party favors go straight in the trash when parents clean out backpacks. These actually survive the purge.
Keep a few boxes around for favor bags. Parents genuinely appreciate school supplies disguised as party favors. Sneaky? Yes. Effective? Also yes.
Crayola Colored Pencil Set, 12 Ct, Pre-sharpened
Sounds weird but hear me out. Toss one in with the candy and parents love you for it. A dentist mom at our party literally high-fived me.
Colgate Harry Potter Kids Toothbrush, Extra Soft, 2pk, Small
Swap disposable cups for these and kids use them at home for weeks. My neighbor's kid still drinks juice out of the one from our party six months ago.
Way To Celebrate Disposable Plastic Cups, Blue, 8.79 fl oz
Slide a pack into each bag and you've given a gift that lasts longer than the sugar high. Teachers have thanked me for this one, which felt oddly validating.
Cra-Z-Art Classic Multicolor Broad Line Washable Markers
Try these for kids who are over stickers. They scratch off the black coating and find rainbow underneath. Kept a car full of kids quiet for 20 minutes, which is a miracle.
Melissa & Doug Scratch Art Bookmark Party Pack Activity Kit
Hand these out and kids sit down and focus for a solid chunk of time. My friend called them ‘tiny babysitters’ and honestly she's not wrong.
Fun Express Amazing Year Maze Puzzles - 24 Pc
Use these for a summer party and every kid walks out looking like a tiny celebrity. They actually wore them for weeks after, which surprised me honestly.
WAY Widowed & Young - Bereavement support UK
Bulk Buys That Save You From Last-Minute Panic
Nothing worse than realizing at 9pm the night before that you're short on favors for six kids. These bulk packs mean you always have backup.
Grab one of these and you're set for multiple parties. I bought it in January and I'm still pulling from it in October. The variety keeps things fresh each time.
Fun Express - Sticky Assortment (100 Pc) - Toys - Value Toys
Stash this in the pantry and pull from it whenever a party pops up. Between school events and birthday parties, you'll burn through it faster than you think.
Airheads Candy Variety Bag
Snag this if you're throwing a big party and need volume fast. It covers toys, noise makers, and small games all in one box. Lifesaver at 10pm the night before.
Peppa Pig 'Confetti Party' Favors Mega Mix Value Pack
Stuff a deflated balloon in each bag as a bonus. Kids love blowing them up later and it costs you basically nothing per bag. Stretch that budget.
Way To Celebrate, 12" Standard Mix Latex Balloons
Buy once and you're covered for the entire birthday party season. I keep mine in a big jar by the front door and grab a handful whenever I need bag filler.
Wholesale Spangler Dum Dum Pops 300CT (Pack of 3)
Toss a sheet or two in every bag without even thinking about it. At this quantity you could fill bags for every kid in your child's entire grade and still have some left.
Fun Express Bulk 24 Pieces Happy Easter Sticker Sheets
Pick this up at the start of the year and forget about tattoo shopping for every single party. Throw five in each bag and kids think they hit the jackpot every time.
Shop Best Sellers Temporary Tattoos