Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried Equate Sunscreen Against Dermatologist Brands and My Skin Couldn't Tell
42
items Spending $40 on a 2oz tube of sunscreen every month felt ridiculous, but switching to drugstore felt like gambling with my face. So I ran a summer-long experiment comparing Equate and store-brand SPF to the pricey stuff my derm recommended. If you're...
Sections
6
Daily Face Sunscreens Under $10 That Actually Wore Well
Body Sunscreens for People Who Hate Reapplying
Mineral and Sensitive Skin SPF That Won't Irritate
Water-Resistant SPF for Pools, Lakes, and Beach Days
After-Sun and Recovery Products for When You Mess Up
SPF Lip and Eye Protection Most People Forget About
Daily Face Sunscreens Under $10 That Actually Wore Well
My old $38 face sunscreen left the same white cast as the $7 one. Once I realized that, I started testing every affordable option I could find. These sat under makeup without pilling or making me look greasy by noon.
Grab this if you've been paying triple for a lightweight SPF 50 that disappears. Applied it every morning for six weeks and my foundation sat on top like nothing was underneath. Zero white cast on my medium skin tone.
Equate Ultra Light Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 100, 6 fl oz
Use this on days you're outside more than usual. Feels almost identical to Neutrogena's version but costs about half. A coworker literally thought I was wearing the name brand when she borrowed some at lunch.
Equate Ultra Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 70
Keep this around for sensitive skin days when chemical filters sting. The tint blends in enough that I skip foundation on weekends. Worth every cent if your face turns red from most sunscreens.
CeraVe Sunscreen Tinted Hydrating 100% Mineral
Compare this side by side with the Equate version before you commit to paying more. I wore one on each arm for a week and genuinely couldn't feel a difference. Your wallet will notice though.
Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunscreen SPF 55
Try this if you want the dermatologist gold standard to benchmark against. It IS smoother, I'll give it that. But at $35 a bottle, you better really love that texture because the protection level matched my cheaper picks.
La Roche-Posay Anthelios Melt-In Milk Sunscreen SPF 60
Toss this in your gym bag for outdoor workout days. Survived a 5K in August humidity without dripping into my eyes. For the price of a coffee, you get a full-size bottle. Stock up before summer.
Equate (Walmart) Sport Lotion SPF 50 Sunscreen Review
Pair this with the Equate version and test them yourself. Sun Bum smells better, no argument there. But my tan lines (or lack thereof) were identical on both arms after a beach weekend.
Sun Bum Original SPF 50 Sunscreen Lotion
Body Sunscreens for People Who Hate Reapplying
Reapplying sunscreen every two hours sounds great in theory. In practice, I'm covered in sand with sticky hands and zero motivation. These lasted longer on skin and made the whole process less annoying.
Bring this to every cookout. The spray is even, dries fast, and I stopped dreading reapplication because it takes about 15 seconds. My arms matched protection-wise against the $12 Coppertone spray.
Equate Sport Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Spray
Switch to this only if you need water resistance for actual swimming. Otherwise the Equate spray performed the same on dry land. I burned with neither after four hours of yard work.
Coppertone Sport Sunscreen Spray, SPF 50, 1.6 oz
Snag this for the kids who run away mid-application. The wide spray pattern catches more skin in one pass. Cheaper than most sport sprays and held up through a slip-and-slide afternoon.
Banana Boat Kids Sport Sunscreen Spray Lotion SPF 50, 6oz
Use this on your shoulders and chest if you burn within 20 minutes like I do. SPF 100 is overkill for most people, but some of us are translucent and need the extra buffer. Costs under $8.
Equate Ultra Light Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 100, 6 fl oz
Get this if you're actually in the ocean all day, not just sitting near it. It stuck through waves better than any spray I tested. Pricier than Equate but earned it during a snorkeling trip.
Neutrogena Beach Defense Sunscreen Spray Broad
Keep this by your back door for quick errand runs. SPF 30 is plenty for a grocery trip or walking the dog. Moisturizing enough that I skipped body lotion underneath. Two birds, one $5 bottle.
Equate Beauty All Day Moisturizing Sunscreen Lotion
Try this if your legs look ashy five minutes after applying regular sunscreen. The hydrating formula actually made my skin look better, not just protected. Costs more than Equate but your dry skin will thank you.
(2 pack) Coppertone Sport Sunscreen Lotion
Mineral and Sensitive Skin SPF That Won't Irritate
Chemical sunscreens made my neck break out in tiny bumps for years before I realized mineral was the fix. These zinc-based options protected without the reaction, and not all of them cost a fortune.
Grab this before you spend $22 on a boutique mineral sunscreen. It left a slight white cast on darker skin tones, but on fair to medium skin it blended fine. My eczema patches didn't flare once.
Equate Ultra Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Lotion
Use this if your skin throws a tantrum at everything. The bottle cap changes color in UV light which is a neat trick for reminding you to reapply. Dermatologists recommend it constantly for a reason.
Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen - Sport, SPF 30+, 5 Oz
Pair this with your CeraVe moisturizer if you're already in that routine. Ceramides in a sunscreen sounded gimmicky until my winter-wrecked skin actually felt softer after wearing it all day.
(2 pack) CeraVe Hydrating Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50
Swap to this from chemical SPF if you've noticed tiny bumps on your forehead every summer. Took me three years to connect those dots. Zinc cleared it up within a week of switching.
Neutrogena Sheer Zinc Dry-Touch Sunscreen Lotion
Toss this in the diaper bag but honestly, adults with reactive skin should try it too. No fragrance, no stinging, and it passed my “wear it on a sunburned face” test without making me cry.
(4 pack) Equate Baby Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Lotion
Try this if you want mineral protection that feels more like a regular lotion. The oat formula calmed down redness I didn't even know I had. Pricier than Equate but the texture is noticeably smoother.
Aveeno Protect + Soothe Mineral Sunscreen Stick
Get this for your kids and then secretly use it yourself. No chemical filters, reef safe, and it survived a pool day without reapplication better than half the adult sunscreens I tested.
Thinkbaby Sunscreen - Safe - Baby - Spf 50 Plus - 6 Oz
Water-Resistant SPF for Pools, Lakes, and Beach Days
I ruined a vacation once because my sunscreen washed off in the hotel pool within 30 minutes. Spent the rest of the trip looking like a lobster. Never again. These actually stayed put in water.
Bring this to the pool if you're doing casual swimming, not training for the Olympics. Held up for about 60 minutes of splashing around. At this price point you can reapply generously without wincing.
Equate Sunscreen Sport SPF 50 Lotion, 8 fl oz
Use this when you're actually doing laps or surfing. It gripped skin better than the Equate sport version in heavy water contact. The price difference is about $4, which is worth it for a full beach day.
Coppertone Sport Sunscreen Spray, SPF 50, 1.6 oz
Snag this if you want to smell like vacation without buying a separate fragrance. Water resistance was decent for light swimming. My wife and I split a bottle over a long weekend and still had some left.
Hawaiian Tropic Sheer Touch Ultra Radiance Lotion
Spray this on squirmy kids between cannonballs. Dries faster than the lotion version so they actually let you finish applying. Worked just as well on my adult arms during the same pool session.
Equate Kids Sunscreen Spray, SPF 50, 11 oz, 2 Count
Keep this in your beach bag for midday reapplication when the sun is brutal. SPF 70 in a spray format means you actually use enough product. Smells like coconut and held up through body surfing.
Sun Bum Refreshing Face Mist Sunscreen, Original, SPF 45, 3.4 oz
Try this if you need something that won't slide off during a kayaking trip. Thick enough to stick but not so thick you feel coated. Cost me $7 and outlasted a $30 sport sunscreen on the same trip.
Banana Boat Sport SPF 50 Sunscreen Lotion
Ditch the fancy packaging and just get protection. No-Ad literally puts all the budget into the formula instead of marketing. Survived a full day at the water park with two kids and zero burns on anyone.
No-Ad 50 SPF Sport Sunscreen Lotion 16oz
After-Sun and Recovery Products for When You Mess Up
Sometimes you forget to reapply. Sometimes you fall asleep on a float. It happens. These kept a mild burn from turning into a peeling disaster and got my skin back to normal faster than just suffering through it.
Grab this the second you feel that tight, hot skin feeling. Threw it in the fridge for an hour before applying and it felt like a cold compress. Under $4 and works identically to the name brand version.
Walmart
Use this if you want something slightly thicker than pure aloe. It stayed on skin longer without that sticky residue. My sunburned shoulders stopped hurting enough to sleep comfortably that same night.
Banana Boat, Soothing After Sun Aloe Gel, 16 fl oz
Slather this on once the initial burn calms down. Your skin is going to peel if you don't lock in moisture early. I layer it over aloe gel and the combo shortened my recovery from a week to about three days.
CeraVe Moisturizing Cream, Rich Face and Body
Dab this on the worst spots, like nose tips and ear tops that always catch extra sun. Feels greasy but creates a barrier that lets damaged skin actually heal. My dermatologist literally prescribed this after a bad burn.
Aquaphor Healing Ointment Skin Protectant for Dry
Keep this in your medicine cabinet for burns that itch like crazy while healing. Takes the inflammation down within an hour. Don't use it for more than a few days though, your skin gets dependent.
Walmart
Switch to this about three days post-burn when your skin starts flaking. The cocoa butter softens peeling skin enough that it doesn't look like you're shedding. Cheap enough to apply three times a day without guilt.
Equate Beauty Moisture Cocoa Butter Care Lotion, 10 fl oz
Toss this massive bottle in your beach house rental. It's 24 ounces for a few bucks and everyone in the group will need it at some point. Works exactly like the small fancy tubes but you won't run out mid-trip.
Fruit of the Earth, Aloe Vera Gel, 12 oz, Unscented
SPF Lip and Eye Protection Most People Forget About
Burned my lower lip so badly once that it blistered for a week. Couldn't eat, couldn't smile, couldn't stop thinking about how I protect every other body part except my face's most sensitive spots. Fixed that problem permanently.
Toss one in every bag you own. Burned lips are miserable and nobody thinks about them until it's too late. Tastes like mango, feels like regular chapstick, and saved me from a repeat of the blister incident.
Sun Bum Sunscreen Lip Balm, Coconut, SPF 30, 0.15 oz
Grab this three-pack and leave them everywhere, car, kitchen drawer, backpack. SPF 45 on your lips for under $3. I compared it directly to the Sun Bum and my lips stayed unburned with both.
Banana Boat Lip Balm SPF 45
Use this for daily commuting when you're not at the beach. SPF 20 handles incidental sun exposure and the tint options mean you can skip lipstick on casual days. Multitasking at its simplest.
Neutrogena Revitalizing Tinted Lip Balm, SPF 20
Keep this in your hiking pack. It didn't melt in my car like some other lip SPFs did during a July road trip. Stayed solid, applied smooth, and my lips survived a 6-mile exposed trail.
Coppertone Sport Sunscreen Lip Balm SPF 50
Get real UV protection for your eyes instead of relying on gas station shades. The polarization cut glare on water so well I actually spotted fish while kayaking. Your eye skin wrinkles faster without proper UV blocking.
Walleva Black Polarized Replacement Lenses for Maui Jim
Snag these if you lose sunglasses constantly and can't justify spending $200. Full UV400 protection, polarized lenses, and I've sat on two pairs without breaking them. Real protection at a price that doesn't sting.
Panama Jack Wrap-Around Polarized Sunglasses
Swipe this around your eyes and on your ears without getting lotion in your actual eyeballs. The stick format gives you precision that sprays and lotions can't match. My under-eye area stopped burning once I added this step.
Neutrogena Ultra Sheer SPF 60 Face Sunscreen Stick