Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best Restaurants & Places to Eat Near Our Vacation Rentals
19
items As a local and vacation rental host, I'm always scouting the best restaurants to recommend to our guests. These are the spots my family and I genuinely love — from quick casual bites to date-night favorites. Every restaurant on this list has been per...
Map
Sections
1
Casual & Family-Friendly
Casual & Family-Friendly
Family favorite and is perfect for littles just as much as adults
Zama Mexican Restaurant
The ambiance, the food, the view is just outstanding. Out r favorite spot to watch 4th of July fireworks!
Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila
Outdoor ambiance is perfect for those coastal evenings or upstairs seating for cooler days.
Harry's Seafood
Our absolute favorite breakfast spot in St. Augustine! The chicken biscuit is unreal and the vibes are so cozy. We go here almost every time we're in town. Be ready for a wait on weekends but trust me it's worth it!
The Blue Hen Café
Such a cool spot right on the water! The food is amazing, the coffee is on point, and the whole vibe is so laid back and beachy. We love coming here for a chill breakfast or lunch. Their Saturday sunset tacos are a must if you're in town on a weekend...
Ragga Surf Cafe
This is our go-to for a special night out in downtown St. Augustine. Right off St. George Street, the food is incredible — fresh seafood, amazing steaks, and the flavors are so unique. Perfect for date night or a celebration dinner. Make a reservatio...
Collage
The coolest restaurant and bar in St. Augustine hands down. It's in this gorgeous old ice factory building and the cocktails are next level. The menu is small but everything on it is amazing. We always end up here on our nights out. The atmosphere al...
Ice Plant Bar
Right on St. George Street so you can't miss it. The food is great, the cocktails are fun, and they have live music every night which makes it such a good time. It's got this cool speakeasy vibe that we love. Perfect spot to grab dinner and stay for ...
Prohibition Kitchen
If you love seafood this place is a dream. Right on the waterfront with the most gorgeous views. The fish is always super fresh and they do it so well — try the fried clams or the oyster po'boy. It feels upscale but still casual enough to show up in ...
St. Augustine Fish Camp
Such a gem on Charlotte Street! They do farm-to-table seafood and everything tastes so fresh. The menu changes with the seasons which keeps it exciting every time we go. Smaller spot so definitely make a reservation. One of the best dining experience...
Catch 27
Hidden gem alert! This place is tucked away on Aviles Street and it feels like you've stepped into a European cafe. The food is so creative and beautifully presented. It's intimate and romantic — perfect for a special dinner. One of those places that...
Forgotten Tonic
One of the most popular restaurants in downtown St. Augustine and for good reason! They source everything locally and the Southern-inspired dishes are so good. The outdoor patio is beautiful and the brunch is insane. We recommend this one to literall...
The Floridian Restaurant
Oh my gosh this place is SO good. The ramen is next level and the chef blends Japanese and French techniques which makes everything taste so unique. It's reservation only so plan ahead but it's absolutely worth it. One of those spots that makes you f...
Lotus Noodle Bar
We love this place! The pretzels are so soft and warm and perfect for snacking while you walk around downtown. But honestly our favorite thing is their garden area — it's such a cute little outdoor spot to sit and enjoy your pretzel. The kids love it...
Ben's Soft Pretzels
This place is such a vibe! Right across from the Castillo de San Marcos with the most incredible views of the waterfront. The rooftop lounge is where you want to be — grab a cocktail and watch the sunset over the bay. The food is really good too, gre...
River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge
Our go-to pizza spot for ordering in! We love grabbing a couple pies from St. Augie's and eating them in the backyard of our homes. The pizza is legit NY style — thin crust, great sauce, and the pepperoni is always crispy on top. It's perfect for a l...
St. Augie's Pizza – St. Augustine, Florida
If you love wine and French food this is your place! It's this cozy little bistro on Charlotte Street with an amazing wine list and the food has such a French flair to it. Everything feels so intimate and special — perfect for date night or a girls n...
The Drunken Horse St. Augustine
Such a fun and creative restaurant! The food is this amazing Caribbean-Southern fusion and every dish feels like an adventure. The appetizers are so creative and the fish is always fresh. The vibe is artsy and fun — not your typical St. Augustine res...
Blackfly The Restaurant
A St. Augustine classic! Columbia is Florida's oldest restaurant and the St. George Street location is gorgeous — the courtyard with the fountain is so beautiful. The Spanish-Cuban food is amazing, you have to try the 1905 salad and the Cuban sandwic...
Columbia Restaurant