🍰 Milk Bar Best Sellers - Birthday cake truffles, cookie tins and sweet gift boxes that ship nationwide. The tastiest holiday gift! ✨
Milk Bar's iconic rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake - the one that started it all. 13K+ reviews. Ships nationwide.
6" Birthday Cake
Best Sellers #2 pick. One of each Milk Bar cookie in a 6-count tin — the easiest nationwide cookie gift.
Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
Beautiful x Milk Bar collab with Drew Barrymore. A buttercream shortbread baking mix that bakes up into Milk Bar's signature sweet. Fun DIY gift that ships.
Beautiful x Milk Bar Buttercream Shortbread Mix
Milk Bar's gooey, legendary Pie - sticky buttery crust, crème fraîche & chocolate chips. A cult favorite that ships nationwide. $53.
Milk Bar® Pie
A dozen rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake truffles - all the childhood flavor in a sweet little box. The perfect sweet gift that ships. $40.
B'Day Truffle Dozen Box
Rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake truffles in a gift-ready pack. The iconic B'day flavor, bite-sized, ready to ship to anyone. $43.
Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
A dozen chocolate chip cookie truffles - Milk Bar's buttery, brownie-ish cookie flavor in bite-sized form. An easy sweet gift that ships. $40.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle Dozen Box
Milk Bar Pie meets SKIPPY in a chocolate-peanut-butter-crunch pie. Smooth chocolate shell, salty-sweet PB filling - the unexpected gift that ships. $58.
SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
The Milk Bar Pie recipe in cozy fall mode - pumpkin-spiced, all-butter crust, holiday gift-ready. A seasonal bestseller that ships. $55.
Pumpkin Milk Bar® Pie
3 of each Milk Bar fan-favorite cookie in one 12-count tin - Compost, Confetti, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow and more. A big cookie gift that ships. $48.
The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
A B'day-flavored no-brainer gift box: cake, truffles and the heavy hitters all in one. Milk Bar's all-out celebration bundle that ships. $99.
The Big B’Day Gift
Milk Bar's big rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake for parties of 30-40. The iconic B'day flavor scaled up - the ultimate sweet gift that ships nationwide. $140.
10" Birthday Cake
Milk Bar's iconic rainbow-flecked Birthday Cake, now gluten-free. The same B'day flavor with 1,640 reviews - an inclusive sweet gift that ships nationwide. $78.
6" Gluten-Free Birthday Cake
Milk Bar's signature baked-goods gift set - B'day Cake, cookies and truffles together. The original, no-fuss gift box that ships nationwide. $97.
The Birthday Classic
A mix-and-match dozen of Milk Bar's Birthday cookies in one 12-count tin. The fan-favorite assorted cookie gift that ships nationwide. $48.