Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Made an Old Fashioned That Tastes Like a $18 Bar Cocktail
24
items Spending $15-18 per drink at cocktail bars was bleeding my wallet dry, but every attempt at home tasted like cough syrup with ice. If you're the person who orders an Old Fashioned every single time but winces at the check, this is the exact setup tha...
Sections
4
Cocktail Infusion and Smoking Kits
Bitters, Syrups, and Mixers That Actually Matter
Glassware and Tools for a Proper Setup
Whiskey and Bourbon Worth Mixing
Cocktail Infusion and Smoking Kits
My Old Fashioneds used to taste flat and one-dimensional, like bourbon with sugar water. These kits added the layers of flavor I kept tasting at bars but could never replicate at home.
Grab this if you've ever wondered why your home cocktail tastes nothing like the smoked one at the bar. First time I torched cherry wood chips over my glass, my wife walked in and asked who was bartending. The smoke flavor actually sticks around inst...
Aged & Charred Whiskey Smoker Kit with Torch, Syrup & 8
Try this before your next dinner party. Dropped in some oak chips and vanilla on a Tuesday, and by Friday I had something that tasted like it aged for months. Perfect for anyone who drinks mid-shelf bourbon but wants top-shelf flavor without the pric...
DO Your Whisky | DIY Whiskey Infusion Set
Keep this in your bar cart if you get bored making the same drink every weekend. Six different wood chip flavors means six different versions of your go-to cocktail. Cherry wood with rye whiskey was the combo that made me stop ordering out.
Cocktail Infusion Kit with, Oak Wood Tools
Use this when you want the smoke without the full torch setup. Pointed it at a glass of bourbon and orange peel, and the result tasted like something a bartender with a waxed mustache would charge me $20 for. Compact enough to store in a drawer, whic...
The Smoking Gun Food Smoker, 18/8 Stainless Steel
Pair this with any brown spirit and watch people's faces when you lift the lid. Brought it out at Thanksgiving and my father-in-law, who has never complimented anything I've made, asked for a second round. The cedar plank option hits different with b...
Crafthouse by Fortessa Glass Cocktail Smoking Box
Snag this if you already own a torch and just need the smoking piece. Fits right over a rocks glass, no extra equipment cluttering your counter. I burned through three cheaper versions that cracked before finding this one, so learn from my mistakes.
Cocktail Smoker Kit with Wood Chips and Torch -Old
Bitters, Syrups, and Mixers That Actually Matter
Turns out the difference between a sad home cocktail and a bar-quality one was never the bourbon. It was everything else in the glass. Swapping grocery store maraschino syrup for real ingredients changed everything overnight.
Get this first if you own nothing else on this list. A few dashes completely changed my drink from “bourbon and sugar” to an actual cocktail. Been using the same bottle for four months and it's barely half empty, so the value per drink is ridiculous.
Angostura Aromatic Bitters, 4 fl oz, Liquid Cocktail Mixers
Switch to these when you want a slightly different profile from Angostura. A little more spice, a little less clove. I alternate between the two depending on whether I'm using rye or bourbon, and both versions slap.
Fee Brothers
Ditch the simple syrup you made from white sugar and water. This has gum arabic in it, which gives the drink a silky texture I could never figure out how to replicate. One bottle lasted me about 40 cocktails, so do the math on cost per drink versus g...
Liber & Co. Classic Gum Syrup | Enhance Your Cocktails
Toss those neon red cherries in the trash right now. These taste like actual fruit instead of candy, and dropping one in the glass makes the whole drink look like it belongs on Instagram. Yes they're pricey, but one jar lasts weeks unless you start e...
Luxardo, Gourmet Maraschino Cocktail Cherries, 400g Jar
Try adding two dashes alongside your regular bitters for a cherry-forward Old Fashioned that doesn't taste artificial. A buddy who bartended for eight years told me this was his secret weapon. He was right and I'm still a little annoyed he waited so ...
Woodford Reserve Spiced Cherry Bourbon Barrel Aged
Keep this around for when you want to branch out from Old Fashioneds into gin and tonics. Homemade tonic from this syrup versus canned tonic water is a gap so wide you'll feel personally offended by every flat Schweppes you ever drank.
Jack Rudy Small Batch Classic Tonic Syrup
Glassware and Tools for a Proper Setup
Drank my first 50 homemade cocktails from a regular kitchen glass and wondered why the experience felt off. The right glass changes how the drink smells, how it hits your lips, and honestly how seriously you take the whole process.
Swap out your regular tumblers for these. The weight alone makes the drink feel more intentional. Thick base keeps everything cold longer, and they survived my dishwasher for three months straight without a single chip. Good for anyone building a bar...
Libbey Craft Spirits Assorted Liquor Glasses (Set of 6)
Bring these out when company comes over. The cut crystal catches light in a way that makes your $30 bourbon look like it costs three times more. Handed one to my neighbor and he immediately asked where I got them.
Godinger 25722 Dublin Crystal Whiskey Glass 11oz, Set of 4
Grab the full kit if you're starting from zero. Jigger, strainer, muddler, bar spoon, all in one box. Before this I was measuring bourbon with a “generous pour” which is code for “way too much.” Accurate measuring alone improved my drinks by 50%.
FineDine 14 Piece Stainless Steel Bartender Drink Mixer Set
Use fresh juice or don't bother. Sounds dramatic but the difference between bottled lime juice and a fresh squeeze is night and day. This press gets every last drop out and takes up almost no drawer space. My old method was squeezing by hand like som...
Zulay Kitchen Large Manual Citrus Juicer Press
Get these before your next batch of Old Fashioneds. A big ice sphere melts slower, which means your drink stays strong instead of turning into bourbon-flavored water by the halfway point. Fills easily, freezes overnight, pops out clean every time.
Sphere Ice Molds Set of 2 Ice Ball Maker
Pair this with fresh orange peel and a sugar cube for the traditional method. Sturdy enough that it won't flex when you press down, and the textured base actually grips the fruit instead of just pushing it around. Replaced a wooden one that started s...
OXO SteeL Muddler with Non-Scratch Nylon Head and Soft
Whiskey and Bourbon Worth Mixing
Spent way too long using bottom-shelf bourbon and wondering why my cocktails tasted harsh. You don't need the expensive stuff, but you need the right stuff. These sit in that sweet spot where they mix well without making your wallet cry.
Start here if you're only going to buy one bottle. Smooth enough to sip straight but has enough character to stand up to bitters and smoke. This is what finally made my home Old Fashioned taste like a real drink instead of a science experiment.
Buffalo Trace, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 750 ml
Switch to rye when you want a spicier, drier Old Fashioned. Rye was actually the original spirit for this cocktail, and once I tried it with Angostura bitters and an orange peel, bourbon started feeling almost too sweet. Stock up because once you go ...
Bulleit 95 Rye Whiskey, 750 mL Glass Bottle, 45% ABV
Use this when you're making drinks for someone you're trying to impress. Vanilla and caramel notes come through even with bitters and smoke layered on top. Brought a bottle to a friend's housewarming and left with three people texting me for the reci...
Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Grab this for a bolder, higher-proof Old Fashioned that doesn't get lost under ice and mixers. At 101 proof it punches through where smoother bourbons sometimes fade. My go-to for cold weather when I want something with real backbone.
Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon, 750 ml Bottle, 50.5% ABV
Try this if you liked Bulleit Rye but want something with more depth. Bottled in bond means 100 proof and a flavor that holds up against heavy smoke and rich syrups. A bartender friend called this the best value rye in America and I haven't found a r...
Rittenhouse Straight Rye Whisky Bottled in Bond
Keep this as your everyday sipper and mixer. Wheated bourbon means it's softer on the palate, which works great if you're newer to whiskey or making drinks for someone who usually orders vodka sodas. The red wax cap also looks great sitting on a bar ...
Maker's Mark, Straight Bourbon, 750 mL Bottle, 45.0% ABV