Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Stopped Weekend Boredom by Filling a Baking Challenge Basket Every Saturday
33
items Weekends used to blur together — same couch, same scrolling, same nothing. Then I started putting together a basket with ingredients and a recipe card, and now Saturday mornings actually feel like something. Whether you bake solo, drag a partner into...
Sections
11
The Basket Itself
Flour Power Picks
Sugars and Sweeteners
Leavening and Baking Basics
Butter Eggs and Dairy
Chocolate and Mix-Ins
The Basket Itself
Started with a random cardboard box and it fell apart mid-flour-explosion. Learned the hard way you need something sturdy that also looks good sitting on the counter waiting for Saturday.
Grab this if you want something that actually holds a bag of flour without buckling — I tried three flimsy ones before landing here and it sits on my counter all week looking intentional.
Mainstays Oval Natural Seagrass Storage Basket
Use the chalkboard label to write this week's challenge recipe name — my kids started getting excited when they'd spot a new title on Friday nights.
The Better Homes & Gardens Medium Black Wire Basket
Keep a few of these stacked in your pantry for when you want to gift someone a baking challenge basket — did this for my sister's birthday and she called it the best present she'd gotten in years.
Pen+Gear Large Moving and Storage Box
Flour Power Picks
Ran out of regular flour once mid-recipe and tried to substitute with cornstarch. Don't be me. Having a few flour types on hand means you can tackle basically any recipe that lands in the basket.
Toss this in every single basket — it covers 90% of recipes and the bag reseals decently so it won't coat everything in white dust like my first attempt did.
Gold Medal All Purpose Flour, Baking Flour, 5 lb Bag
Switch to this when you want the basket challenge to feel slightly less guilty — made banana bread with it last month and honestly couldn't tell the difference.
Bob's Red Mill Whole Wheat Flour, 5 lbs.
Snag this specifically for any cake or cupcake challenge weeks — the texture difference is wild and my coworkers started asking if I'd ordered from a bakery.
King Arthur, Cake Flour Unbleached And Unenriched
Sugars and Sweeteners
Week three I realized I only owned granulated sugar and the recipe called for brown sugar and powdered sugar. That was the week we made sad cookies. Never again.
Keep this permanently stocked — sounds obvious but I ran out at 9 PM on a Saturday once and had to drive to the store in my pajamas.
Domino Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 4 lb. Bag
Grab the dark brown over light if you're only picking one — it works in more recipes and gives cookies that deep caramel chew that makes people hover around your kitchen.
C&H Premium Pure Cane Dark Brown Sugar 2lb. Zipper-Pak
For anyone who wants frosting or glaze options without a special trip — I dust this on French toast too when it's not baking day, no regrets.
Domino, Confectioners Sugar, Pure Cane 10-X Powdered
Leavening and Baking Basics
Nothing kills the mood faster than pulling out a recipe and realizing your baking powder expired in 2021. Ask me how I know. These three sit in every basket rotation.
Try tapping some into water before using — if it fizzes, you're good. Saved me from flat muffins after I found a can that had been hiding in my cabinet since the pandemic.
Clabber Girl Gluten-Free Double Acting Baking Powder 8.1
Get the bigger box because you'll use it for cleaning up flour disasters too — dual purpose for people whose counters look like a crime scene after baking.
ARM & HAMMER, Baking Soda, 1 lb Box
Ditch the imitation stuff — the first time I used real vanilla in chocolate chip cookies my husband literally stopped mid-bite and asked what was different.
McCormick, Vanilla Extract, 2 fl oz, Non-GMO, Pure
Butter Eggs and Dairy
Forgot to soften butter once and tried microwaving it. Ended up with butter soup. Now I pull dairy items the night before and stage them like a cooking show contestant.
Use unsalted so you control the salt level — I made salted caramel brownies with salted butter once and they tasted like the ocean in the worst way.
Land O'Lakes Unsalted Butter, 8 Half Sticks, 1 lb Pack
Bring eggs to room temperature before mixing — cold eggs seized up my batter one Saturday and we spent 20 minutes trying to fix lumps that never went away.
Great Value Large White Eggs, 12 Count
Snag this for pound cake and coffee cake weeks — sounds weird but it makes everything ridiculously moist and my neighbor literally asked for the recipe after one bite.
Daisy Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 16 oz (1 lb) Tub
Chocolate and Mix-Ins
Plain baked goods are fine but the basket gets way more exciting when there's a bag of chocolate chips peeking out. My kid now digs through the basket looking for these first.
Throw these into basically any cookie or muffin recipe even if it doesn't call for them — nobody in the history of baking has complained about surprise chocolate chips.
Nestle Toll House Real Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels
Keep this around for any chocolate cake or brownie challenge — I made a mug cake at midnight with this once and it was better than most restaurant desserts I've paid $14 for.
Hershey's Natural Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, Can 8 oz
Pair these with brown sugar recipes like pecan pie bars — my Thanksgiving version made my mother-in-law go quiet, which from her is basically a standing ovation.
Fisher, Chopped Pecans, 16 oz, Gluten Free No
Spices That Actually Matter
Had a spice rack full of things I bought once in 2019. Threw them all out and started fresh with just the ones that show up in baking recipes constantly.
Use this generously in anything apple or pumpkin themed — stale cinnamon tastes like dust so if yours has been open more than a year, swap it out now.
McCormick Kosher Ground Cinnamon, 2.37 oz Bottle
Try a tiny pinch in your next banana bread — it's that background flavor you can't identify but makes people say ‘why does yours taste different’ every time.
McCormick Kosher Ground Nutmeg, 1.1 oz Bottle
Grab this before snickerdoodle week — I skipped it once thinking it was optional and ended up with flat sad sugar cookies instead of the puffy tangy ones.
McCormick All Natural Kosher Cream Of Tartar, 1.5 oz Bottle
Recipe Card and Planning Supplies
Scribbling recipes on napkins worked for exactly two weeks before I lost three of them. Having actual cards in the basket made the whole thing feel like a real tradition instead of a chaotic impulse.
Toss a fresh card in the basket each week with the recipe written out — my daughter started decorating them and now we have a little collection pinned to the fridge.
Jot & Mark Recipe Cards 4x6 Inches Blank Double Sided
Use different colors for different difficulty levels — red means hard, green means even the 6-year-old can lead. Keeps expectations honest.
Sharpie Permanent Markers, Fine Point
Slide your recipe card into one of these before baking starts — learned this after chocolate batter splattered across a card and I couldn't read step four anymore.
Avery Diamond Clear Heavyweight Sheet Protectors
Measuring and Mixing Tools
Borrowed my roommate's warped measuring cups for months before realizing my cookies were inconsistent because nothing was actually measured right. Proper tools fixed everything overnight.
Get a set that nests and won't bend — my old plastic ones warped in the dishwasher and I was unknowingly adding extra flour to everything for weeks.
KitchenAid, 9-Piece Plastic Stackable Measuring Cup
Use glass for liquids so you can actually see the line at eye level — I overpoured milk in a cake recipe three times before someone told me this basic trick.
Pyrex, Measuring Cup, 2-Cup, Glass with Red Graphics
Snag metal ones because the plastic ones snap when you dig into packed brown sugar — broke two sets before I stopped being cheap about measuring spoons.
KitchenAid Stainless Steel Measuring Spoons - Walmart.ca
Baking Pans and Sheets
Tried baking cookies on a warped dark pan once and half were burnt while half were raw. The pan matters more than I ever wanted to admit.
Swap your old dark pan for this lighter one — dark pans run hot and that's probably why your cookie bottoms keep burning, not because your oven is broken.
Wilton, Recipe Right Cookie Sheet Set
Keep this as your go-to for brownies, sheet cakes, and bar cookies — it handles everything and I've had mine for two years of weekly challenges without a single sticky disaster.
Wilton Premium Steel Non-Stick Oblong Cake Pan with Lid
Grab this for muffin and cupcake challenge weeks — the cups are sized so batter doesn't overflow everywhere like it did with my old pan that was apparently made for ants.
Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan: Mini, 24 cups
Finishing Touches and Presentation
Week one we ate brownies straight from the pan with a spatula. Fine. But once I added some presentation supplies the whole thing felt like an event instead of just Tuesday.
Use the angled tip to frost cakes without dragging crumbs through — went from lumpy disaster frosting to smooth enough that my friend asked if I took a class.
Wilton, Angled Icing Spatula, 9-inch, Black & Silver
Line everything with this and cleanup takes two minutes — before parchment I was soaking pans overnight and still scraping burnt sugar off with a butter knife.
Reynolds Kitchens, Parchment Paper, 45 sq ft, Non-Stick
Try this when the challenge is cupcakes — my 8-year-old made swirl frosting on her first attempt and acted like she'd won a baking show, totally worth the five bucks.
Wilton ColorSwirl 3-Color Coupler Decorating Kit, 9 pc