These are essential spots for treating my very real and serious diagnosis of Sweet Treat Syndrome.
These aren’t made to be super instagrammable and over-the-top. They’re made to be delicious and happen to look really good as a result of the care tha...
Sections
2
Brooklyn
Manhattan
Brooklyn
Chef Morgan KILLED IT with my custom pinball-themed birthday cake
Saint Street Cakes
All pre-order based BUT keep an eye on their IG for extras you can reserve day-of
Loser's Eating House
They are CASH ONLY!!! I know it’s not the most convenient in this day and age but carrying cash for spots like this comes in so clutch.
PETER PAN DONUTS
Great year-round spot for ice cream OR hot chocolate. Marshmallows are made in-house!
Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain
Great spot to stop by on the way to the Pinball Museum
Baked NYC
The last of a dying breed. They’re most known for their candy apples (or as they’re called here, jelly apples), but don’t sleep on the marshmallow sticks!
William's Candy Shop
This is a common recommendation but I promise it’s for a reason!! Pick up a chocolate raspberry swingle and get a great look at the Statue of Liberty from the pier next to the building.
Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie
Manhattan
THEE best choco chip cookie in NYC, argue with the wall
Culture Espresso
A great break spot for the girlies working in FiDi or tourists passing by City Hall Park
Takahachi
Apple pie crust cookie over everything
Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods
Ube vanilla swirl soft serve 🔛🔝
Soft Swerve
The ice cream sandwich is massive and should probably be split with someone
Supermoon Bakehouse
Cash only and dirt cheap. Pick up a sweet treat and watch the fearless pigeons in the park across the street!
