Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Mature Skin Makeup That Actually Works

Purple Star emoji 17 items
I get asked about my makeup constantly, so here’s what I actually use and love. I’m fair-skinned with cool undertones, hazel eyes, and salt and pepper hair. These products work for mature skin without settling into fine lines, emphasizing texture, or...
Sections
4
 
 
 
 

Base

The foundation (pun intended) of any good makeup routine. These products prep, perfect, and protect your skin while giving you the coverage level you actually want that day.
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
This primer is specifically formulated for mature skin and creates the perfect canvas. Your makeup goes on smoother and stays put longer.
Battle Prep - Smoothing Face Primer
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
My go-to for “I want coverage but not a full face” days. It’s got SPF built in and evens out your skin tone without feeling heavy. Perfect for running errands or casual days. I use shade “Pearl”
Tinted Moisturizers: Natural, Oil Free, & with SPF
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
When I want actual coverage, this is what I reach for. It goes on smooth, doesn’t settle into fine lines, and gives that lit-from-within glow without looking shiny. I use shade 0,5N
Dior Forever Skin Glow: Hydrating Face Foundation
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
This concealer doubles as a color corrector and it’s incredibly versatile. Some days I just mix a bit of this with my SPF and I’m done. It blends beautifully and doesn’t crease. I use shade 0,5N
Dior Forever Skin Correct - Concealer and Corrector

Color

Blush and contour to add dimension and life back into your face. Because mature skin needs strategic color placement, not heavy-handed application.
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
A little goes a long way with this one, which I love. It’s buildable, blends easily, and works great on mature skin without emphasizing texture. I use shade Peony.
Beauty Concepts Liquid Blush Duo * ROSE & PEONY *
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
This is a grey-toned contour, which is perfect if you’re cool-toned like me. No orange muddy bullshit. Plus the applicator makes it easy to get precise placement. I use shade Soft Tan
Sun Sculpt Liquid Contour-Warm Honey

Eyes

From everyday neutrals to dramatic looks, these products deliver pigment and staying power without the fallout or creasing that plagues so many eyeshadows and liners.
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Beautiful colors with great pigment that glides on without tugging. This palette does exactly what it’s supposed to do.
Smashbox Covershot Palette - Punked - 0.21 oz - Ulta Beauty
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Highly pigmented, buttery smooth, and the color payoff is incredible. These are my luxury splurge palettes and worth every penny. I use palettes Galactic and Night Walk
Diorshow Eyeshadows Designer Eye Palettes - Makeup
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Glides on effortlessly and actually stays put. No raccoon eyes by midday.
Black Card Liquid Eyeliner
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
This is my tightlining holy grail. It’s precise, stays where you put it, and doesn’t smudge into your waterline. I use Black Screen
Epic Wear Waterproof Eyeliner Stick
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Long-wearing mascara that doesn’t flake or smudge. Gives great length and curl without clumping.
Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Refillable Mascara
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Foolproof brow filling that looks natural. The shape makes it easy to create hair-like strokes. I use shade 6
Goof Proof Brow Pencil

Lips

My most extensive category because I’m particular about lip products. Whether you want a bold red, a subtle tint, or something that lasts through coffee and conversation, I’ve got you covered.
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Strawberry Sangria is THE PERFECT RED. It goes on like a gloss so you can wear it shiny, or wipe it off for a subtle tint. No peeling off that awful black film like some other lip stains. This is the one.
Poutsicle Hydrating Lip Stain
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
If you don’t mind the peel-off application, this is my favorite long-wear option. The color payoff is incredible and it lasts all damn day. I use Glamorous (red) and Whimsical (neutral)
WONDER BLADING All-Day Lip Stain - WONDERSKIN
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Long-wearing and beautiful. This tint gives you that “my lips but better” vibe that actually lasts. I use Natural Berry
Dior Addict - Transfer-Proof Hydrating Lip Tint
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Great for when you want just a hint of color. It’s comfortable to wear and doesn’t dry out your lips. I use Sassy Stuff
Smushy Soft Matte Tinted Lip Balm | NYX Professional Makeup
 
Melanie | Your Witchy Mother profile picture
Drugstore option with serious staying power. You get long wear without the luxury price tag. I use Shanghai Sizzle
Revlon ColorStay Moisture Stain Milan 030