Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best & Toughest Dog Toys
16
items If your dog is a toy destroyer, you’re not alone. This list rounds up the toughest toys out there—tested and approved by my own power chewers. From indestructible stuffed animals to long-lasting balls and interactive toys, these picks hold up to teet...
Sections
3
Durable Stuffed Animals
Tough as Balls: Toughest Balls
Curated Collection from Benable Lists
Durable Stuffed Animals
Soft doesn’t have to mean weak. These stuffed toys combine cuddly with tough—reinforced stitching, squeakers that survive, and fabric that holds up to the gnawing and tugging of determined dogs. If your pup loves plush but tends to “de-fluff,” these ...
This Buck Wild toy from BarkBox’s Super Chewer line is one of the few that stands up to intense gnawing and shredding. It’s durable without being boring—our dogs go wild for the texture and shape. Great for keeping heavy chewers busy and happy.
Barkbox Buck Wild Super Chewer Dog Toy
One of the toughest soft toys out there—seriously. This TUFFY duck has multiple layers and reinforced stitching, making it a plush toy that can actually stand up to tug, toss, and gnawing. Bonus points: it floats, squeaks, and you can toss it in the ...
TUFFY Barnyard Junior Duck Dog Toy - Durable
Tough, quiet, and perfect for rough play. This TUFFY warthog skips the squeaker but still brings the fun. With multiple layers and reinforced seams, it’s built for dogs who love to tug, toss, and chew. It floats, it’s machine washable, and it actuall...
TUFFY Desert Warthog Dog Toy - No Squeaker
Surprisingly tough for such a soft, snuggly bunny. Walter Wabbit is a favorite in our house—super plush on the outside, but built with a durable inner layer that holds up to rough play. It’s great for cuddling and chasing, and it doesn’t fall apart a...
Fluff & Tuff – Walter Wabbit Plush Dog Toy
No stuffing = no mess, just nonstop tug-and-shake fun. This 22" Skinneeez toy stretches, crinkles, and squeaks—keeping dogs engaged without turning your living room into a fluff explosion. Great for tug-of-war and fetch, especially with multiple dogs...
SPOT Skinneeez Stretch & Squeak Dog Toy
Tough, quiet, and made from natural materials—this little fox gets chewed on daily. With no squeaker, no fluff, and extra-thick leather and felt, this toy holds up to aggressive chewers and teething pups alike. It’s small but mighty—perfect for focus...
Pet Supplies : SPOT Dura-Fused Chunkies Fox
Perfect for keeping curious pups busy and mentally engaged. These squeaky, crinkly hide-and-seek toys are great for solo or supervised play. Dogs love pulling the mini toys out, and the octopus adds a fun twist. It’s a playful way to burn energy indo...
4 Pcs Interactive Hide and Seek Dog Toys
A tough, crinkly squeaker toy with no fluff and no mess—just fun. These SHARLOVY toys are built with 6 layers for extra durability, making them ideal for chewers and teething pups. They squeak, crinkle, and hold up longer than most plush toys—plus, n...
SHARLOVY No Stuffing Crinkle Squeaky Dog Toy
Tough as Balls: Toughest Balls
The only ball my dogs haven’t destroyed—and they’ve tried. This ultra-durable rubber ball is perfect for fetch, tug, and serious chewing. It’s highly visible, built for aggressive chewers, and comes with a lifetime replacement guarantee. If your dog ...
WoofBite Indestructible Dog Ball - Yellow
A nearly indestructible ball with a built-in squeak—what’s not to love? This heavy-duty ball is made for aggressive chewers who still want a little squeaky fun. It holds up to rough play, works indoors or out, and gives just enough bounce and sound t...
ZRIFAQESW Tough Dog Chew Toys, Indestructible
A fetch favorite—bouncy, tough, and it even floats. These Chuckit! Ultra Balls are perfect for medium to large dogs who love to chase. They’re made from durable rubber that holds up to repeated play, and the bounce keeps things exciting. Bonus: they ...
Chuckit! Ultra Ball Dog Toy - Medium - 2 Pack
A solid variety pack for serious chewers—great value, great durability. This SHARLOVY 6-pack includes tough cotton rope toys and durable balls built for aggressive chewers. Whether your dog loves to tug, chew, or chase, there's something here to keep...
SHARLOVY Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers
KONG Extreme Ball with Hole - Fetch Toy - Durable Dog Toy for Training, Interactive Playtime & More - Natural Extreme Rubber Ball - Black - for Large/Medium Dogs
KONG Extreme Ball - Durable Fetch Toy - Black
A fetch toy, tug toy, and herding ball all in one. This QDAN soccer ball has grab straps that make it easy for dogs to carry, chase, and tug. It floats, holds up to rough play, and is the perfect size for small to medium dogs. Bonus: it makes an awes...
QDAN Dog Soccer Ball Toy with Straps, 6 Inch
Big, bouncy, and basically indestructible—perfect for dogs who love to herd and chase. This 8" Jolly Pets ball floats, bounces, and keeps its shape even after serious play. It’s great for the yard, beach, or lake, and big enough that it doesn’t get l...
Jolly Pets Large 8" Soccer Ball Dog Toy
Curated Collection from Benable Lists
There are so many great lists on Benable - here is one for our dogs.
Dog Toys for Heavy Chewers