Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Fajita Night Made Easy – Everything You Need to Cook & Serve
76
items Fajita night made simple, fun, and full of flavor. This curated collection of my favorite ingredients, kitchen tools, toppings, sides, drinks, desserts, and after-dinner extras for creating an unforgettable fajita night. Whether you're making chicken...
Sections
10
👩🍳 Make It From Scratch
🍽️ Kitchen Tools & Cookware
🥘 Ingredients & Pantry Staples
🧀 Cheese Picks & Toppings
🥫Salsas & Sauces
🌮 Sides To Serve With
👩🍳 Make It From Scratch
Making fajitas from scratch is easier than ever—these slow cooker recipes, simple tools, and pantry staples do the heavy lifting so you don’t have to.
Watch & Cook: Slow Cooker Chicken Fajitas — easy step-by-step video and full recipe from Slow Cooking Perfected for a flavorful, fuss-free dinner.
Slow Cooker Chicken Fajitas
Slow Cooker Chicken Fajitas Recipe — tender, flavorful, and incredibly easy; a one-pot Tex-Mex favorite from Slow Cooking Perfected.
Slow Cooker Chicken Fajitas
Slow Cooker Steak Fajitas Recipe — easy 5-ingredient meal with round steak, peppers, onions, and salsa for a flavorful, fuss-free dinner.
Slow Cooker Steak Fajitas
Watch: How to Make Corn Tortillas — step-by-step video using Maseca masa to make fresh, authentic tortillas at home.
How to Make Authentic Tortillas
🍽️ Kitchen Tools & Cookware
Essential kitchen gear for prepping and cooking slow cooker fajitas with ease. From slow cookers to cast iron pans, these tools make it all happen.
Cast iron fajita pan with wooden tray — perfect for serving slow-cooked fajitas with sizzling, restaurant-style flair.
Bayou Classic Cast Iron Fajita Pan with Wooden Tray
Compact 4-qt Hamilton Beach slow cooker with 3 heat settings and dishwasher-safe crock—ideal for small meals or side dishes.
Hamilton Beach 4-Quart Slow Cooker, 3 Settings
6-qt Hamilton Beach Stay or Go slow cooker with locking lid and dishwasher-safe crock—perfect for family meals or potlucks.
Hamilton Beach 6-Qt Portable Slow Cooker
Extra-large 10-qt Hamilton Beach slow cooker with locking lid, perfect for meal prep, parties, and easy cleanup.
Hamilton Beach 10 Qt Slow Cooker, Portable
Tortilla Lovers Gift Pack (5-piece set) — includes masa mix, tortilla press, comal, cookbook, and warmer for making perfect homemade tortillas.
Tortilla Lovers Gift Pack 5 items
Tortilla & pancake warmer — keeps tortillas soft and warm for serving fajitas, tacos, or fresh-off-the-comal pancakes.
Tortilla & Pancake Warmer Plastic Large 9"
Nordic Ware microwave tortilla & pancake warmer (10") — quickly heats and keeps tortillas soft and steamy for serving fajitas or breakfast favorites.
Nordic Ware 10-Inch Microwave Tortilla and Pancake Warmer
Since you're having fajitas, you might as well have some margaritas. This machine will make them for you.
Nostalgia 1 Gallon Margarita & Slush Machine, Aqua
Margaritaville Bali Frozen Concoction Maker — blend up margaritas, daiquiris, or mocktails with ease for a fun, festive fajita night upgrade.
Margaritaville Bali™ Frozen Concoction Maker with Self Dispenser
🥘 Ingredients & Pantry Staples
All the ingredients you need to make chicken or steak fajitas—fresh, canned, and seasoned. Includes spices, proteins, tortillas, and everything in between.
Premium boneless, skinless chicken breast from Meat N’ Bone — high-quality, hand-trimmed, and perfect for everyday recipes.
Chicken Breast (Boneless, Skinless) | 3 Pieces
Boneless chicken thighs — all-natural, tender, and ideal for slow cooking.
Chicken Thighs (Boneless, Skinless)
Want a juicy, flavorful cut for fajitas? Try hanger steak—it's rich, tender, and grills up beautifully when sliced thin.
Hanger Steak is a great in fajitas!
This is my go-to for classic fajitas—lean, super flavorful, and easy to slice after grilling or slow cooking. Meat N’ Bone’s Prime flank steak always turns out great.
Flank Steak | Wagyu BMS 7+
If you want to level things up, try this Wagyu flap steak. It’s insanely tender and marbled—perfect for rich, juicy fajitas that feel a little extra.
Flap Steak | Wagyu BMS7+
Green bell peppers — fresh, crisp, and perfect for adding flavor and color to your slow-cooker fajitas.
Green Bell Peppers Fresh Produce by Pound
Organic bell peppers (red, yellow, or orange) — vibrant, sweet, and perfect for adding color and flavor to fajitas or grilled veggie sides.
Organic Bell Peppers
Organic yellow onion — sweet, savory, and perfect for adding depth to your slow-cooked chicken fajitas.
Organic Yellow Onions
Diced tomatoes with green chilies — adds just the right kick and richness to your slow-cooker fajitas.
Amazon Fresh Diced Tomatoes w/ Green Chilies 14.5oz
Medium heat chili powder — rich, earthy heat to deepen the flavor of your fajitas.
Chili Powder, Medium
Ground cumin — warm, smoky spice that adds depth to your fajita seasoning blend.
Cumin, Ground Seeds
Hungarian sweet paprika — mild and vibrant, it brings rich color and subtle sweetness to your fajitas.
Paprika, Hungarian Sweet
Granulated garlic — bold, savory flavor that blends seamlessly into your slow-cooked fajitas.
Garlic, Granulated
Sizzlin’ Fajita Seasoning — a bold, all-in-one blend that replaces cumin, chili powder, and paprika with perfectly balanced fajita flavor.
Sizzlin' Fajita Seasoning
Sea salt, to taste — Pacific fine sea salt adds clean, balanced seasoning to bring out the best in every bite.
Sea Salt, Fine
Black pepper, to taste — finely ground Tellicherry pepper for a fresh, bold kick to finish your fajitas.
Pepper, Fine Grind
Soft taco flour tortillas — Guerrero’s classic, pillowy tortillas that wrap your slow-cooked fajitas perfectly.
Caseras Fajita Flour Tortillas
🧀 Cheese Picks & Toppings
All the melty, creamy, crunchy extras—shredded cheese, crema, guac, and more to top your perfect fajita.
1 cup shredded Murray’s Aged English Cheddar — creamy, mellow, and perfectly melty for topping fajitas with rich, balanced flavor.
Murray’s Aged English Cheddar – sweet and crumbly with a slight crunch. | Murray's Cheese
1 cup shredded Grafton Village 1-Year Cheddar — smooth, tangy, and melt-friendly for adding bold, creamy flavor to your fajitas.
Grafton Village 1 Year Cheddar Bar - a creamy, mild Vermont cheddar cheese | Murray's Cheese
1 cup shredded Beecher’s Just Jack — creamy, mild, and ultra-melty for the perfect cheesy fajita finish.
Beecher’s Handmade Cheese Just Jack – mild, milky cheese | Murray's Cheese
1 cup shredded Maple Leaf Pepper Jack 🌶️— smooth-melting cheese with a spicy kick, perfect for turning up the heat on your fajitas.
Maple Leaf Pepper Jack – a balanced, flavorful pepper jack cheese | Murray's Cheese
1 cup shredded Queso Oaxaca — traditional Mexican melting cheese with a mild flavor and perfect stretch for authentic fajitas.
Queso Campesino Oaxaca Mini – a Mexican string cheese | Murray's Cheese
Crema (sour cream), optional — rich and tangy Los Altos Crema Centro Americana adds smooth, authentic flavor to your fajitas.
Crema Centro Americana Los Altos Sour Cream (Pack of 3)
🥫Salsas & Sauces
From mild to fiery, these salsas and sauces bring bold flavor, heat, and zest—perfect for topping fajitas or scooping with chips.
Herdez Salsa Casera (Mild, 7 oz) — fresh, chunky salsa with authentic flavor, perfect for dipping or topping your fajitas.
Salsa Casera Herdez Medium
La Victoria Thick 'N Chunky Salsa – Hot (15.5 oz) — bold, zesty heat and hearty texture make this a perfect topping or dip to spice up your fajita night.
Thick 'N Chunky Salsa La Victoria - Salsas - Hot - 15.5 oz
Guacamole salsa, optional — Herdez’s creamy, zesty blend of tomatillo and avocado brings bold flavor and a little heat.
Herdez Guacamole Salsa Medium
🌮 Sides To Serve With
Quick and delicious sides to round out your meal—Spanish rice, beans, grilled corn, and more.
Zatarain’s Spanish Rice (6.9 oz, 4-pack) — bold, savory flavor that makes the perfect side dish for slow cooker fajitas.
Zatarain's Spanish Rice, 6.9 oz (Pack of 4)
Organic corn on the cob — fresh, sweet, and perfect for grilling or roasting as a flavorful side with your fajitas.
Organic Corn
La Costeña Refried Black Beans (20.5 oz, 3-pack) — creamy, seasoned black beans that make an easy, authentic side for fajitas and tacos.
Black Beans - La Costena Refried Black Beans 20.5 oz (Pack of 3)
DEL MONTE Golden Sweet Whole Kernel Corn (15.25 oz) — crisp and naturally sweet, perfect as a quick side or base for elote-style corn.
DEL MONTE Golden Sweet Whole Kernel Corn 15.25oz
🪅 Table Touches
Add festive flair to fajita night with colorful serveware, napkin holders, and dinnerware. These details bring warmth, charm, and fun to the table.
Handmade Oaxaca ceramic napkin holder — adds vibrant, authentic Mexican charm to your fajita night table setting.
Handmade Pastoral Oaxaca Ceramic Napkin Holder (Mexico)
Set of 6 hand-blown Mexican confetti glasses (10 oz) — vibrant and festive, perfect for serving margaritas, agua fresca, or iced tea with your fajitas.
Dos Suenos Hand Blown Mexican Drinking Glasses - Set of 6 Confetti Rock Tumbler Glasses (10 oz each)
Cobblestone jute table runner (13x36") — adds natural texture and rustic warmth to your fajita night table setting.
Cobblestone Jute Rect Runner 13x36
Zulay metal lemon & lime squeezer — the perfect tabletop tool for adding a fresh citrus burst to your fajitas.
Zulay Kitchen Metal 2-In-1 Lemon Squeezer Manual
Handmade olive wood lemon reamer — a rustic, elegant tool for squeezing fresh lime or lemon juice right at the table.
BeldiNest Citrus Juicer Olive Wood Run Lemon Reamer, Wooden Lime Squeezer
Set of 2 handmade Mexican pottery dip bowls — ideal for serving salsa, guacamole, or crema with authentic style and charm.
Handmade Mexican Pottery Black Appetizer and Dip Bowls (Set of 2) - 3" x 2"
Talavera Dinnerware Collection — vibrant, hand-painted style inspired by Mexican pottery, perfect for serving colorful, festive fajita-night meals.
Dolores Dinnerware Collection
Talavera Bowls — hand-painted stoneware bowls that add vibrant Mexican flair to your table, ideal for serving rice, beans, or fajita toppings.
Dolores Bowls
Set of 4 handmade cobalt blue margarita glasses — festive and authentic, perfect for serving cocktails or mocktails on fajita night.
NOVICA Artisan Handblown Recycled Margarita Glasses Blue Cocktail Drinkware Clear Mexican Tableware 'Happy Hour'(set of 4)
Set of 4 handmade sapphire globe wine glasses — bold, beautiful, and perfect for pouring Spanish wine with your steak fajitas.
NOVICA Artisan Handblown Recycled Wine Glasses Blue Clear Mexican Cocktail Drinkware 'Sapphire Globe'(Set of 4)
JoyJolt Layla crystal wine glasses (set of 2) — sleek, modern, and elegant for serving red or white wine with your fajita night spread.
JoyJolt Layla European Crystal Stem 16.9 oz Red Wine Glass, Set of 4 - 17 oz
Hand-blown Mexican glass pitcher (84 oz) — vibrant and functional, perfect for serving agua fresca, margaritas, or citrusy mocktails on fajita night.
Dos Suenos Mexican Hand Blown Glass Pitcher - Cobalt Blue Rim and Handle (84 oz)
Williams Sonoma Corn Holders — sturdy and stylish, perfect for serving grilled corn or elote alongside your fajitas without the mess.
Corn Holders, Set of 4
🍷Drinks to Serve With
Refreshing drink pairings for fajita night—margaritas, mocktails, Jarritos, wine, and more to complement every bite.
Having chicken fajitas? Pair it with Bodegas Shaya Organic Verdejo 2022. This crisp, citrusy white balances the fajita spices and brightens every bite—especially if you're loading on the guac, crema, or lime. It’s fresh, clean, and just the right mat...
Bodegas Shaya Shaya Old Vine Organic Verdejo 2022 - 750 ML
Pair it with steak fajitas for a rich, balanced red that brings out the smoky, savory flavors without stealing the show.
Marques de Riscal Rioja Reserva 2020 - 750 ML
Celebrating with steak fajitas? Pair them with Marqués de Murrieta Rioja Reserva 2019 — an elegant Rioja with rich red fruit and spice that adds a refined touch to fajita night.
Marques de Murrieta Rioja Reserva 2019 - 750 ML
Corona Gift Basket — a fun, ready-to-serve beer set that pairs perfectly with fajitas, chips, and sunshine.
Corona Gift Basket
Classic Margarita Cocktail Kit — everything you need to shake up the perfect margarita for a festive fajita night at home.
Classic Margarita Cocktail Kit
Margarita Gift Basket (choose your tequila) — a festive, customizable set perfect for pairing with fajitas, chips, and all the fixings on taco or fajita night.
Margarita Gift Basket - Choose Your Tequila
Tequila Sampler Set — a tasting-ready lineup of premium tequilas, perfect for sipping alongside fajitas or serving up a DIY margarita bar.
Premium Tequila Sampler
Truly Fiesta Hard Seltzer Set — light, fizzy, and fun—perfect for sipping while you cook, snack, or serve up fajitas.
Truly Tequila Soda Fiesta Pack
🍮 Dessert to End on a Sweet Note
Churro Making Kit — a fun, hands-on dessert to finish fajita night with warm, crispy churros and sweet dipping sauces.
Harry & David: Online Gift Baskets, Fruit and Food Gifts & Wine Clubs
Tres Estrellas Churros Mix (17.6 oz) — make hot, crispy churros at home with this easy-to-use flour blend—perfect for dipping and dessert after fajitas.
Churros - Tres Estrellas Churros Flour Mix 17.6 oz.
McConnell’s Orange Cream Sherbet — a cool, citrusy treat that’s light, creamy, and the perfect sweet finish to fajita night.
Orange Cream Sherbet
McConnell’s Dark Chocolate Sorbet — rich, smooth, and dairy-free; the perfect indulgent (but light) way to end fajita night on a cool note.
Dark Chocolate Sorbet
McConnell’s Brazilian Coffee Chip Ice Cream — bold coffee flavor with chocolatey crunch, perfect for pairing with churros or enjoying as a rich, creamy dessert after fajitas.
Brazilian Coffee
Bocadín Chocolates by Ricolino — crispy wafer bars covered in creamy chocolate, perfect for a sweet, nostalgic finish to your fajita night.
Bocadin Chocolates by Ricolino
🎉 After Dinner Fun – Games, Sips & Sweet Finishes
Keep the good vibes going after fajitas with classic games, smooth sips, and flavor-packed extras. Whether you're pouring a little Don Julio, brewing rich Mexican coffee, or breaking out a round of Lotería, these picks help you unwind, connect, and c...
Lotería Mexican Bingo Game — a colorful, classic game to keep the fun going after fajitas; perfect for family or fiesta nights.
Lotería - Mexican Bingo
Don Julio Tequila Gift Set — a smooth, premium tequila pairing perfectly with dessert, after-dinner cocktails, or a relaxed sip to end fajita night.
Don Julio Tequila Gift Set
Mega Chamoy Sauce (Original) — tangy, sweet, and spicy; drizzle over fruit, rim cocktail glasses, or add a zesty kick to your fajita night drinks and snacks.
Mexican Coffee 100% Cafe Arabica Ground Dark Roast
Mexican Train & Chickenfoot Scorecards — the perfect companion for your domino game night, keeping the fun going long after the fajitas are gone.
Mexican Train and Chickenfoot Scorecards - 5x2x.3 in.
Wooden domino & card holders (set of 4) — perfect for Mexican Train or card games after fajitas, keeping your hands free for dessert and drinks.
GSE™ Set of 4 Wood Domino & Playing Card Racks, Wooden Domino Trays/Holders for Mexican Train Dominoes and Cards Games
5211 Azul Edition Card Game — fast-paced, colorful, and easy to learn—perfect for winding down fajita night with a little friendly competition.
5211 Azul Edition Card Game | Fast Playing Strategy Game