Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Best Ice Cream Places in Western PA

Purple Star emoji 12 items
Looking for ice cream in Western Pennsylvania? These are the favorites the locals rave about.
Sections
2
 
 

Ice Cream

These are little places in our community that have the best ice cream. I even included a few franchises, because they are well worth a visit.

 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
My workplace every May will get every employee a pint of Katie's Korner Ice Cream. It is delicious! If you're ever in the area I highly recommend it.
Katie's Korner: Home
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
If you're in the area, this is a great ice cream place to check out.
Millie's Homemade (Ice Cream)
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
If you like Milkshakes, this has a great selection! I love that my area has so many ice cream places to choose from.
MilkShake Factory
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
If you are in the area and only have time for one ice cream place, this is the one to try!
NatuRoll Creamery
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
Not exactly in the Pittsburgh area, but Penn State Berkey Creamy has really good ice cream. They even it ship it out of state!
Penn State Berkey Creamery
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
Very cute and fun ice cream shop. Definitely worth the stop if you're in the tiny city of Beaver.
Witch Flavor?, Inc.
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
Another great stop for ice cream if you're in the area. Originally from Youngstown, it has found a home here, too.
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
From bakery to gelato, they have some of the best desserts in the area. They are even in the Grove City Outlet Food Court. So if you're up there shopping, grab a sweet treat there.
Tinman Sweets
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
Also known for it's wood fire pizza, it started out as a gelato stand. If you're in the area and looking for some authentic Italian Food, stop by.
Mercurio's Restaurant

Frozen Custard Stands

Frozen custard looks similar to ice cream, but has a different flavor. If you are an frozen dessert connoisseur you definately need to check out these places. 

 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
Glen's serve more than just dessert. And instead of ice cream, this is custard. Delicious! Also check them out for birthday parties.
Glen's Custard
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
This is a favorite ice cream and taco place of nearly everyone in the area. Instead of a dining area, it has picnic tables outside. Everyone looks forward to opening day. Hanks is always busy, but it's worth it.
Hanks Frozen Custard
 
Kim Hilbert profile picture
This small little place is one of the best custard places in western PA.
Dellas Frozen Custard