Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Where To Eat In The FL Keys
14
items Have a trip to the FL Keys planned? Here are my must-try favorites for a happy belly in paradise.
Map
Sections
4
Breakfast
Lunch & Dinner
Unique Dining Experiences
Key Lime Pie
Breakfast
Start your day off right in paradise.
Casual, affordable, friendly staff, delicious homestyle menu! You will not be disappointed. I recommend visiting a few times to try different options because it's all good, and choosing what to order is a tough decision.
The Stuffed Pig
You can't go wrong with the pancakes or the lobster benedict. Fun atmosphere, indoor/outdoor dining. Also open for lunch and dinner.
Blue Heaven
Budget friendly, good food, small diner, cozy comfort vibe.
Wooden Spoon
I can't leave without getting my coffee at Cuban Queen Coffee, if you are a coffee lover, it will be your happy place.
Cuban Coffee Queen Waterfront
Lunch & Dinner
I have never had a bad meal here.
Perfect for lunch or dinner, on the water, gorgeous sunset views, excellent staff, I love the whole vibe of this place. The food is fresh and good, you will not go hungry, the portions are big.
Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar
This is another repeat place for us, consistently great food, large portions, and I suggest taking a stroll along the dock to look at the boats.
Island Fish Company
When someone asks where to go for good steak and seafood, my answer will always be The Florida Keys Steak And Lobster House. It's not just good though, it is excellent. The service, the food, you will not be disappointed. One visit and I bet it's add...
Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House
The perfect after dinner spot to take care of the sweet tooth. They have a little bit of everything and it's all homemade. I personally love their ice cream!
Sweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys
Unique Dining Experiences
Restaurants that have something a little extra.
Dinner with a beautiful sunset view, live music, public pool, games, and boat parking.
Sunset Grille & Raw Bar
If you are looking for an experience this is a wonderful option with waterfront dining, shops and you can feed the super-sized tarpon. Definitely order a cocktail or two, they make them good here.
Robbie's of Islamorada
A dive bar in the middle of no where with walls filled with dollar bills. Not only is the food great (I recommend a cold beer and a burger) but you will be greeted by few friendly wild deer and chickens on your way in.
No Name Pub
Key Lime Pie
You just need to try them all and decide for yourself.
Good crust and a nice balance of tart and sweet.
Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - Elizabeth Street
This is my husband's favorite, if you like more of a cheesecake style plan a stop here.
S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill
Graham cracker crust with a creamy custard texture, add this to your list!
Mangrove Mama's